JeffB |
01-21-2010 04:35 PM |
Nothing is as consistent as Alum/Carbon technology. It's the nature of the beast. when carbon shafts are made, they are what they are, unlike aluminum which can be worked and then precision layers put on top of it, or in the FMJ's case, have the aluminum around it to keep the carbon straight and spine consistent. This is why most all carbons are "graded" into straightness. They are sveral feet long when produced on the mandrel, and then the straighest middle section is sold as the "premium" shaft, and the sloppier ends are sold in lower grades. The MFGR would lose their butt, if they only kept the straight middle sections and ditched the majority of the carbon shaft they are actually producing.
Maximas (and any "spine selected" shaft from CX) are pretty tight spine-wise, but only cos CX spends an vast amount of time matching them up, hence the hefty price tag. Carbon Tech manages to keep spine pretty tight by not mass producing anything, though with the move to china and the mfg/ done by Win & Win, the mass production will be up. I'm curious to see if they can keep the consistency. Easton, considering the vast numbers of shafts they make also does a pretty good job- especially in the price range most of their arrows sell for. Generally they will spine better than a comparable price shaft from CX, GT, Victory, etc (who often tout straightness as the
be-all end-all to shaft consistency, when in truth spine and weight is far more critical). Beman quality though, in my experience has really gone downhill-total crapshoot- it's obvious the C2 ICSH (now outdated) construction and the "axis seconds" are just not up to snuff with their Easton counterparts in consistency.
As for bending. A/C/C/s will bend. Do they bend as easily as an aluminum arrow. Nope. But if they take severe hits- either front impacts, or say nock end hits in group shooting- they can bend or crease. But it's not easy. FMJs will definitely bend easier in my experience, but I absolutely love them- fantastic shooting shaft-straight, and great spine consistency. I am currently up in the air whether I want to stick with FMJs or go back to my old reliable ACCs. I've pretty much had it with any of the current all-carbon offerings, I'm sick of buying a dozen arrows (regardless of price) and only getting 6 or 7 that are worth a crap.
|