HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   Arrow weight vs Arrow speed (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/296893-arrow-weight-vs-arrow-speed.html)

TFOX 07-02-2009 10:57 AM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

ORIGINAL: drockw

Oh yeah, and the distance in drop between 0 and 30yds for the same setups...
398gr. 23in at 30yds. 71in at 50yds
428gr. 26in at 30yds. 75in at 50yds
500gr. 31in at 30yds. 90in at 50yds


That may seem like quite a bit but think about it... Between the lightest arrow and the heaviest arrow there is only 8in of difference in drop at 30yds. When your looking at a target at 30yds, 8in aint a whole lot:D

Now to the site pins... I dont have a way or the time to calculate your pin gap, but all you have to have is a program like AA or TAP or OT2 (archery calculators) to figure it out by measuring your peep to arrow distance at full draw, and your peep to pin distance, along with your arrow weight/length/fletch etc. etc... IF you were to calc. those, im sure you would find that the difference in pin gap is very minimal compared to what most people think...

either way, a well placed shot is what it is. You dont have to be a genius to do that one[8D] Most setups nowadays are SOOOO overly capable that it doesnt even matter, SO.... shoot what you feel comfortable with.

Derek


These are TOTAL drop numbers and when you use a pin,just about useless numbers.The only factor is the actuall miss diference.I still believe the original numbers are not correct.

The miss difference I had at 40 yards with one of my target rigs was only a 1/2" DIFFERENCE in 20 fps on a 3 yard,misjugement of yardage.

Basically,if I shot a 40 yard target for 37 yards,the slower arrow only impacted a 1/2" lower than the faster arrow.

TFOX 07-02-2009 11:05 AM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 
There are MANY factors the come into play when thinking about POTENTIAL penetration that most are completely oblivious too.

Arrow weight,diameter,foc,material of arrow,mass thickness,tune,broadhead style,speed,ke,momentum,all come into play in POTENTIAL penetration.

MeanV2 07-02-2009 11:32 AM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

ORIGINAL: TFOX

There are MANY factors the come into play when thinking about POTENTIAL penetration that most are completely oblivious too.

Arrow weight,diameter,foc,material of arrow,mass thickness,tune,broadhead style,speed,ke,momentum,all come into play in POTENTIAL penetration.
I agree! Nothing is B&W. Most of the times added weight will increase KE out of the same bow.

I prefer at least 6 grains per pound on my hunting setups because the game I hunt does not require extreme penetration and the flatter trajectory is many times a plus.

I really can't remember the last animal I shot that I did not get a pass through on.:D

Dan

drockw 07-02-2009 12:35 PM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

ORIGINAL: TFOX


ORIGINAL: drockw

Oh yeah, and the distance in drop between 0 and 30yds for the same setups...
398gr. 23in at 30yds. 71in at 50yds
428gr. 26in at 30yds. 75in at 50yds
500gr. 31in at 30yds. 90in at 50yds


That may seem like quite a bit but think about it... Between the lightest arrow and the heaviest arrow there is only 8in of difference in drop at 30yds. When your looking at a target at 30yds, 8in aint a whole lot:D

Now to the site pins... I dont have a way or the time to calculate your pin gap, but all you have to have is a program like AA or TAP or OT2 (archery calculators) to figure it out by measuring your peep to arrow distance at full draw, and your peep to pin distance, along with your arrow weight/length/fletch etc. etc... IF you were to calc. those, im sure you would find that the difference in pin gap is very minimal compared to what most people think...

either way, a well placed shot is what it is. You dont have to be a genius to do that one[8D] Most setups nowadays are SOOOO overly capable that it doesnt even matter, SO.... shoot what you feel comfortable with.

Derek


These are TOTAL drop numbers and when you use a pin,just about useless numbers.The only factor is the actuall miss diference.I still believe the original numbers are not correct.

The miss difference I had at 40 yards with one of my target rigs was only a 1/2" DIFFERENCE in 20 fps on a 3 yard,misjugement of yardage.

Basically,if I shot a 40 yard target for 37 yards,the slower arrow only impacted a 1/2" lower than the faster arrow.
Numbers are definately just generated bs, but the gap distance was all i was trying to show... My indoor shafts (500+gr.) usually hit relatively close to where my lighter arrows do at 20yds...

All the #'s that I put out were trajectory numbers as if you were shooting on a perfectly level flat, and off the side of a cliff of course:D

luke/r 07-02-2009 12:47 PM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 
I have a couple questions. What is considered a light arrow? What is considered a heavy arrow? Last year I shot a 330gr arrow and this year I am shooting a 415gr. Is 330grs light and 415 grs heavy? This is with 60lbs.

MeanV2 07-02-2009 01:18 PM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

ORIGINAL: luke/r

I have a couple questions. What is considered a light arrow? What is considered a heavy arrow? Last year I shot a 330gr arrow and this year I am shooting a 415gr. Is 330grs light and 415 grs heavy? This is with 60lbs.
Out of your bow I would consider 330 grain arrow on the light side.

The 415 grain arrow I would consider a medium weight arrow.

Dan

GMMAT 07-02-2009 01:36 PM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 
For a compound bow......

5gpp = light
7gpp = med. heavy
9gpp = really heavy

(My opinion)

luke/r 07-02-2009 03:42 PM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 
Thanks guys.

SteveBNy 07-03-2009 02:58 AM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

Is it easier to stop a sports car going 75mph or a bus going 55mph.
Love this type of "anology"

The bus weighs at least 10 times as much as the sports car.
For the bus/sports car thing to have any meaning, you would have to be comparing
a 300 gr arrow to a 3000 plus gr one. Be interesting to hear what FPS your bow gets with a 3000 gr arrow
and what the trajectory difference would be.

Steve

MeanV2 07-03-2009 03:17 AM

RE: Arrow weight vs Arrow speed
 

ORIGINAL: SteveBNy


Is it easier to stop a sports car going 75mph or a bus going 55mph.
Love this type of "anology"

The bus weighs at least 10 times as much as the sports car.
For the bus/sports car thing to have any meaning, you would have to be comparing
a 300 gr arrow to a 3000 plus gr one. Be interesting to hear what FPS your bow gets with a 3000 gr arrow
and what the trajectory difference would be.

Steve
I agree!!

We are not trying to knock a building down anyway.;)

Dan


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:13 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.