Hunting the same spots.....
#41
I've sat 4 or 5 stands WAY to manytimes but those are whereI see my most deer. I have one honey hole stand that I just about always see deer..
I also have 4 or 5 stands I should have sat more be cause I KNEW there were bucks under them.
Then I had a couple of stands I didn't sit once. I had game cam pics but the stars and winds never aligned.
Ido believe that if I moved around a bit more I would have seen bigger bucks. When you stink up a sight to much the does and young deer might come back but the big ones are tougher to fool.
As a side note, I should have taken the prevailing wind patterns into account while I was setting stands. I put fixed stands in good locations but they required a SW wind and we didn't get ONE day when that happened...
I also have 4 or 5 stands I should have sat more be cause I KNEW there were bucks under them.
Then I had a couple of stands I didn't sit once. I had game cam pics but the stars and winds never aligned.
Ido believe that if I moved around a bit more I would have seen bigger bucks. When you stink up a sight to much the does and young deer might come back but the big ones are tougher to fool.
As a side note, I should have taken the prevailing wind patterns into account while I was setting stands. I put fixed stands in good locations but they required a SW wind and we didn't get ONE day when that happened...
#42
Been hunting hard since october till now, so lets say 80+ sits. In 7 different setups. I places that I have to hunt are only about 15-30 acres max, I can't set up but so many stands.
#44
To be totally fair, Greg....I;d say (based on the size of your IL property) that this attitude is bred out of necessity. It's been pretty well documented (and I know we weren't talking about mature bucks....but I will) that it takes more than we think to make them abandon their home range/core area.
You are right, with mild intrusion, deer will not abandon the property.
[blockquote]quote:
I hunt some of the same stand locations a lot. If one of my stands has been comprimised I'll know it. Deer skirting around the stand or no sightings at all. Then, obviously, I won't hunt it. But, if the deer are still using the trails I'm hunting and acting like they don't know I'm there, I'll keep hunting it when the wind is right.
[/blockquote]
How would you know? Interesting. If we're talking about your IL property....again...with no disrespect.....if you're not seeing them from your stand.....they're probably not on your property (at least this time of year....after leaf drop). How would your feelings change if you were hunting larger tracts? Do you really think it's better to hunt 4 spots on 200 acres.....25X each.....or to mix it up and hunt a different spot, every time? Why do so many people say that your best chance at a deer comes in yur first sit at a new location?
You may sway me to your side.....and I'm ONLY giving a dissenting view. I'd love to further discuss this with you.
Thanks.
_____________________________
I hunt some of the same stand locations a lot. If one of my stands has been comprimised I'll know it. Deer skirting around the stand or no sightings at all. Then, obviously, I won't hunt it. But, if the deer are still using the trails I'm hunting and acting like they don't know I'm there, I'll keep hunting it when the wind is right.
[/blockquote]
How would you know? Interesting. If we're talking about your IL property....again...with no disrespect.....if you're not seeing them from your stand.....they're probably not on your property (at least this time of year....after leaf drop). How would your feelings change if you were hunting larger tracts? Do you really think it's better to hunt 4 spots on 200 acres.....25X each.....or to mix it up and hunt a different spot, every time? Why do so many people say that your best chance at a deer comes in yur first sit at a new location?
You may sway me to your side.....and I'm ONLY giving a dissenting view. I'd love to further discuss this with you.
Thanks.
_____________________________
I have almost always hunted my properties with this approach. However, the size and terrain features dictate where and how many stand sites I will have. No matter what, I like to have at least 1 stand site for every wind direction, as long as I think they'll be productive. Normally I think that less intrusion (bare minimum of stands) is better.
#45
Normally I think that less intrusion (bare minimum of stands) is better.
#46
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
Now we agree. Stands to reason the less times you hunt a spot.....the less intrusion occurs.
Normally I think that less intrusion (bare minimum of stands) is better.
#47
2 properties:
Property A) 6 sits...1 tree...but it's a small setup.
Property B) 35-ish sits...4 trees (two within 20 yards since I moved to get into bow range). I shot a 12pt and a big doe out of the tree that I moved to...that I sat in probably 75% of the time. When I wasn't there...one of my friends were. So from mid-October into mid-November someone was in that stand at bare minimum 4 days a week in the mornings and/or evenings. Total deer out of that stand this year is 6...3 of which were 120" bucks or higher.
It's just an amazing area....where mysteriously the deer keep coming through after all of us walking/sitting/pissing through there...which leads to my theory that deer are really oblivious to the actual threat of the intruders (hunters). "Sit down...shut up...and you'll kill deer." Those are words of wisdom from my grandfather when I was a boy.
Out of the other 3 stands on Property B there were a few other deer taken, non by me...but that's b/c I was either tagged out or they just weren't big enough. I was only busted once this season...while pulling back on a doe. A bunch of other deer picked me off....just one of those deals.
Property A) 6 sits...1 tree...but it's a small setup.
Property B) 35-ish sits...4 trees (two within 20 yards since I moved to get into bow range). I shot a 12pt and a big doe out of the tree that I moved to...that I sat in probably 75% of the time. When I wasn't there...one of my friends were. So from mid-October into mid-November someone was in that stand at bare minimum 4 days a week in the mornings and/or evenings. Total deer out of that stand this year is 6...3 of which were 120" bucks or higher.
It's just an amazing area....where mysteriously the deer keep coming through after all of us walking/sitting/pissing through there...which leads to my theory that deer are really oblivious to the actual threat of the intruders (hunters). "Sit down...shut up...and you'll kill deer." Those are words of wisdom from my grandfather when I was a boy.
Out of the other 3 stands on Property B there were a few other deer taken, non by me...but that's b/c I was either tagged out or they just weren't big enough. I was only busted once this season...while pulling back on a doe. A bunch of other deer picked me off....just one of those deals.
#48
In the early season I tend to move around alot. But my strategy is different when I am hunting closer to the rut.
I pick outa fewspots (normally bottle necks between bedding and feeding areas or between different bedding) that I think will be most productive and stick to them.
I always have at least oneset ready for each wind direction but it is ussually out of the NW or SE around here...meaning much of my time will be spent in just 2 different stands.
In fact mostof thebucks I have killed have come outthe same2 trees.
The last P&Y buck i shot was on aboutmy 12th (guessing) sit in the same tree that season.
I guess I could move around more (I used to hunt many more locations when I first started) but I like to spend the majority of my time in the locations I have the most faith in.
I pick outa fewspots (normally bottle necks between bedding and feeding areas or between different bedding) that I think will be most productive and stick to them.
I always have at least oneset ready for each wind direction but it is ussually out of the NW or SE around here...meaning much of my time will be spent in just 2 different stands.
In fact mostof thebucks I have killed have come outthe same2 trees.
The last P&Y buck i shot was on aboutmy 12th (guessing) sit in the same tree that season.
I guess I could move around more (I used to hunt many more locations when I first started) but I like to spend the majority of my time in the locations I have the most faith in.


