Pics and sheds
 

Here is a pic of a deer I have been after for 2 years I have the sheds from last year and I have a picture from 3 days ago. I know it is hard to tell but is this the same deer

RE: Pics and sheds
 

come on guys no opinion thats not like you people

RE: Pics and sheds
 

It certainly does look like the same one:

RE: Pics and sheds
 

It's really hard to tell from that pic but there is some similarity. The sheds make him look as if he was bigger last year. How many different buck are in the area. What age do you have him pegged at?

RE: Pics and sheds
 

last year he was 147" with a 18in spread as a 4 year old This year he is 5 and I dont think he is any bigger than about 152" just my opinion. That is the only 8 I have seen in the area over 2 years old so I dont think it is a different deer and that pic was taken in the same waterway 100 yards from where I found both sheds last year.

RE: Pics and sheds
 

I would agree that it is the same deer. The left main beam seems to have a distictive curve that you can see in both the trail camera picture and the picture of the sheds. However, I am having real doubts about the 152".

RE: Pics and sheds
 

He was 147 last year. do you think he shrunk from last year?

RE: Pics and sheds
 

Is definately possible.

RE: Pics and sheds
 

He is only 5 I wouldnt think he would be going downhill yet. What do you think the buck in the pic scores?

RE: Pics and sheds
 

It is really hard to tell from that picture, but I would not give him more than 130's. That is just my opinion fromapicture that probably does not give him justice. Some may agree with me and some may not. He is still areal good deer though!!!