New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Well, I was posting this as a Jersey kill but I have my doubts so I edited the post. I recieved the e-mail twice saying it to be a legit Jersey Kill, but you know how that goes. Anyone know anything on this buck? I was told it was killed in Estell Manor New Jersey with a bow and arrow. Actually, to meit looks more like a Texas buck.

I can't say I'm not exited for it to be a legitGarden Statekill...I'm just hoping.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

190" or so. What a pig!!!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

It sure does look like a Texas buck to me too.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I don't know where it came from, but thats one fine buck!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Wow! That's a huge deer!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Big, big deer, but looks like Texas to me as welll. Time will tell.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I bet its a Texas deer, and if it is (and by the looks of it) it doesn't have great mass, it doesn't have G1's or G4's and if its Texas, thats a 20-21" spread and main beams

Just my guess, fine fine buck, NOT world class

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

texas deer for sure if you look at the guys in the picture there all wearing high boots look like snake boots which is common is texas not jersey, pictures worth a thousand words...................

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I live about 20 minutes from estell manor. I have never seen a deer around here with that color hide. Sure would be a monster for around here, jeez its a monster anywhere! I know there are a few hunting clubs up there that have their places fenced in.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

On top of the snake boots is the fact all the guys are in short sleaves and having cold drinks. Most of you guys are starting your stories off with snow, or 17 degrees, so either it was early season up north or Texas.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

You know, pictures are a thousand words....I just noticed the belt buckle on the guy with the beer can in his hand. I guess there can still be a chance, but...well you know how it looks.

Sorry if I posted this prematurely, but I was pretty pumped up. Salem county NJ does have a reputation for some real hogs, even in the 180's to 190's, and that's not too far away from Atlantic co. [&:]

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

that has got to be a record scorer! hes a monster

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

um im curios and confused. how does that not have G1's and G4's? looks wider than 21 to me

[Deleted]
 

[Deleted by Admins]

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

The people in the background look like they are in texas. One has snake boots on. Heck of a buck no matter where you are though

rick

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

With that body style and just the length and spread of those antlers I would say Texas all the way. With being from Maryland I know that I have never seen a deer shot in this area that just has that look to it...

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I would shoot him, no matter what state I was in.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I'll tell you how.

First off, thats a 140 pound live weight Texas buck.

Second, the guy is pushing that deer out as far as he can - and the antlers on that buck is way smaller than the guys grip/hands, indicative of a thing racked buck.

Third, because he's a Texas buck, those ears to ears are what, maybe 14" ?

Fourth, he's a Texas buck, so eyes to nose would measure maybe 6" ... 6 1/2" at most i'd guess and knowing that, those G1's and G4's are not even that long.

Thats a fine buck, in fact a beautiful buck because of antler character and he's got a really good "look" to him.

He's not world class, no where CLOSE to world class though.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

That deer is going to score over 180"!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Without a doubt.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I bet that deer doesn't gross over 150"

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Texas deer in my opinion.. Look at the guys in the background. Plus, look at the deer. It just looks like a texas deer (Im sure some people know what I mean)

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Huh? You havegot to be kidding or please never score one of my deer!

I'll bet you a free whitetail hunt at an outfitter of the winners choice that the deer goes over 150".

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I will agree, that deer is going WELL over 150. Regardless of where he is shot, that is a beautiful buck.

Shane

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

do ya'll know how to score a deer ?

to be 180" that deer would have to have something like this

25" beams
6" G1
13" G2's
12" G3's
6" G4's
18" mass measurements
-------
that's 80" x 2 + 20" spread to equal a 180" buck

I'm seeing a lot less in mass, a lot less in tine length, 20"-22" main beams ... ........ the guy is shoving the deer WAY forward, holding the antlers very lightly to make them appear bigger, its a Texas deer .......


I'd be curious to know the score, maybe I am way way off here ......

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Nice buck!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

im guess low 190s. deer has enough mass and in guessing inside spread is 25"

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

Looks like he came from another planet. Nice one!

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

And I'll bet you'reat least35 inches off;)

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I want some of what you're smokin! Holy crap! [&:]

He's not holding that deer way out. Look at his shoulders. You can plainly see his right arm bent and resting on his leg. His hands are not wrapped around the rack holding on real tight...as he would if he was stretching his arms. His hands are relaxed.

And he doesn't have mass?? Heh?? Have you looked at the bases on that buck? 150= I eat my hat.

Wherever that deer was shot, he's a beautiful buck.

RE: New Jersey Monster?(I hope)
 

I got him at around 170-175"

Hes big no doubt, WAY bigger than 150 i dont care what state hes in, but he probably only has 32" of mass and is no where near as big as he looks. From first glance I thought he looked to be over 185 for sure but after adding him up I really think hes 170s, and in Texas.