Unfair antler scoring system?
 

A fork can score around 50". A small6 might make 80" but probably has 3 times as much actual bone on his head. By a similar ratio, a 150" buck probably has 3 times as much bone on his head yet does not have 3 times the score as the 80". I think a fair way to score would be by total weight though it'd be really hard to try to accomplish that.

Just a thought but you see how it's unfair?

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

Huh?

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

Net score is unfair!

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

I see nothing un far with a net measurement system. Easy to fake weight. you can look at a pic of a 150 and tell he ant 200. I doubt any one ca say that rack weighs 4 pounds not 6

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

You know that the quotation mark stands for inches right? So the scoring system is perfectly fair, a buck that has three times more bone on its head will have three times the score. If the fork horn in your example scored a 50" it would mean it has 50 inches of antler, if the 6 point in your example scored an 80" it means he has 30 inches more antler then the fork horn. Were you under the impression that the quotation mark stood for pounds (as in body weight)? If not I guess i really don't understand your complaint...elaborate please.

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

Alright Steve, let me explain better.

A 50" rack does not physically weigh half as much as a 100" yet it scores half as much. There isa good 3 timesmore bone material on the 100 but it doesn't score 3 times as much as a 50. That's all I'm saying.

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

Think of it like this... A spike gets credit for 4 H measurements when it really should only get 1. I think Hoytail is correct on his thought process... those smaller bucks get alot more credit than what they are worth...

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

i do agree, because of the spread measurements it does seem like its unfair bow a small fork can go 50" and a 100" buck only goes 100" im not sure how to explain it, but i think i know what your saying when you say that its unfair. and the four circumfrence scores even if just a spike that only IMO should get one

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

I don't score. I just weigh the deer for the area I'm hunting. As far as the headgear, I think deductions for extra or short or anything is stupid. If it's there, it should count if that's your thing. I just don't measure and never have.

RE: Unfair antler scoring system?
 

I got ya Hue.