Guardian Vs. Commander Vs. General
 

I have not been on this site much lately due to my wreck. all my time and money has gone into getting my truck fixed. i need yall help and info. which is a better bow. i have heard that each one is better from different people. i would like to know the pros and cons. i remember hearing that the guardian was having limb troubles for a while. im assuming that over with.

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

anyone???

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

For an all around Hunting bow, between those 2, I'd pick the Guardian hands down.

I Loved my Guardian!;)

Dan

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

A general rule of thumb that I was taught was "Long ATA for a long draw, short ATA for short draw". I would say if your draw length is 29" or more then go with the Commander, if it is less then go with the Guardian. I don't think you can go wrong with either choice though.

I hunt with a Commander.

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

the guardian is a better hunting bow, the commander is just too long to hunt with imo. but its whatever you like

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

I have never shot the Commander but I do owna Guardian and love it.

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

ok, thanks, im not to sure what my drawlength is honestly. i need to go to my local shop and have them measure what i'm shooting now. also, is a longer axle to axle going to stabilze my shot more? and which bow is quieter?

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

and which is lighter?

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

The Guardian is lighter, measure your arm span finger tip to finger tip and divide by 2.5 That will give you a very good starting place for your correct Draw length.

In owning a Pro Shop for years, the one thing I saw on a consistent basis was guys shooting a Draw length which was too long.

Dan

RE: Guardian Vs. Commander
 

yeah i believe my current drawlength is about 1/2 an inch long.