Rob's Buck on Video (CLOSE UP VID PG 8)
10-15-2008, 07:13 AM
#121
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Hughesville, PA
Posts: 2,590
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
Guess Rob should have drilled him, scored 60 points for team 15, and then took the pics of the arrow path over the spine.[8D]
If this deer's entry wound was under the spine, he'd be yote food already. Not to mention, IMO walking a little funny, if he wasn't.
If this deer's entry wound was under the spine, he'd be yote food already. Not to mention, IMO walking a little funny, if he wasn't.
10-15-2008, 07:24 AM
#123
Dominant Buck
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
Pops:
I don't have that photo....but do me a favor and remove your white line.......insert another white line below the entrance side tut of hair and stop it at the entrance wound. Now do the same thing on the exit side below the tuft.
Looks a little different when you don't cover up the path, doesn't it.
Like I said.....I don't care anymore (for the sake of this exercise) whether it went above or below the spine....NOR do I think it matters. With the location of the exit wound......if that's an arrow wound.....I think there's some intestinal damage.
I think we'd walk funnier, too if soemone stabbed s with a 12" bowie knife all the way through. But that 4" pen knife can kill you just as dead. Just might take a little longer for you to die.
I don't have that photo....but do me a favor and remove your white line.......insert another white line below the entrance side tut of hair and stop it at the entrance wound. Now do the same thing on the exit side below the tuft.
Looks a little different when you don't cover up the path, doesn't it.
Like I said.....I don't care anymore (for the sake of this exercise) whether it went above or below the spine....NOR do I think it matters. With the location of the exit wound......if that's an arrow wound.....I think there's some intestinal damage.
I think we'd walk funnier, too if soemone stabbed s with a 12" bowie knife all the way through. But that 4" pen knife can kill you just as dead. Just might take a little longer for you to die.
10-15-2008, 08:11 AM
#124
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: Hughesville, PA USA
Posts: 18,322
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
Pops:
I don't have that photo....but do me a favor and remove your white line.......insert another white line below the entrance side tut of hair and stop it at the entrance wound. Now do the same thing on the exit side below the tuft.
Looks a little different when you don't cover up the path, doesn't it.
Like I said.....I don't care anymore (for the sake of this exercise) whether it went above or below the spine....NOR do I think it matters. With the location of the exit wound......if that's an arrow wound.....I think there's some intestinal damage.
I think we'd walk funnier, too if soemone stabbed s with a 12" bowie knife all the way through. But that 4" pen knife can kill you just as dead. Just might take a little longer for you to die.
Pops:
I don't have that photo....but do me a favor and remove your white line.......insert another white line below the entrance side tut of hair and stop it at the entrance wound. Now do the same thing on the exit side below the tuft.
Looks a little different when you don't cover up the path, doesn't it.
Like I said.....I don't care anymore (for the sake of this exercise) whether it went above or below the spine....NOR do I think it matters. With the location of the exit wound......if that's an arrow wound.....I think there's some intestinal damage.
I think we'd walk funnier, too if soemone stabbed s with a 12" bowie knife all the way through. But that 4" pen knife can kill you just as dead. Just might take a little longer for you to die.
Tell me this, if I photo/film that deer weeks from now, you still going to say he'll die eventually? Let's say the blades were down like sled runners and with a blade away from the ribcage, do you honestly think a broadhead would not fit betweent he hide and the ribs without puncturing the cavity.
Next deer I shoot I'm going to slide an arrow exactly where I feel this one is. I find Germ's picture that Pops quoted perfect.
And I find it hilarious if MOTOWN is right about just being tufts of hair. My cuz swears he hit it just over the shoulder which could be the cut on the front shoulder, maybe the deer was hit twice, maybe my cuz is wrong but where did that other cut come from?
Lots of mystery on this one and I'm almost sorry I posted it.
10-15-2008, 08:31 AM
#125
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: TX Panhandle
Posts: 620
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
I like a good mystery.
Go get your cousin, put him back on this deer, have him shoot it, and take pictues of the autopsy.
If the arrow actually went throught the neck, which is also very possible, then all this argument over a wound through the gut that doesn't exist is hilarious.
Go get your cousin, put him back on this deer, have him shoot it, and take pictues of the autopsy.
If the arrow actually went throught the neck, which is also very possible, then all this argument over a wound through the gut that doesn't exist is hilarious.
10-15-2008, 08:52 AM
#128
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Virginia / West Virginia
Posts: 4,906
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
LOL Bryan!
Rob, I bet you are sorry you posted.....WOW did that thread go wild. Its hard to say....to me it looks like BOTH could be wounds, and IMO, that back one (if it is) didn't hit guts and he'll probably be fine.
Rob, I bet you are sorry you posted.....WOW did that thread go wild. Its hard to say....to me it looks like BOTH could be wounds, and IMO, that back one (if it is) didn't hit guts and he'll probably be fine.
10-15-2008, 10:03 AM
#129
Join Date: May 2005
Location: StL, MO
Posts: 745
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
The about the only sure thing I can get out of this thread is that there are still a bunch of people that just cannot understand how much room abovea deer's spine there is for an arrow to go thru, LOL.
10-15-2008, 10:23 AM
#130
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 7,208
RE: Rob's Buck on Video
Even though I posted what I did earlier about a deer living after a shot passing thru its body cavity, I finally had time to look at a lot more of the pics here, and from some angles its hard to tell, but if I were a Referee on sundays..."after further review, the ruling on the field stands, the arrow passed over the deer's spine".
Like I said some angles make it look bad, but the clearest ones I think show it over.
Like I said some angles make it look bad, but the clearest ones I think show it over.