HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   What would he score? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/264883-what-would-he-score.html)

minnesotadeer 09-25-2008 08:24 AM
What would he score?
 
Someone who lives very close to me arrowed this monster two days after our season started. Sorry for the grainy photo but I pulled fromt the paper and scanned. What would this guy score?

silentassassin 09-25-2008 08:32 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
I would say mid 150's. GMMAT posted while I was posting so I could be way off. :DI didn't tally any score just guestimating. I tend to under score on big deer though which is normally a pleasant suprise when you stretch the tape;)I am interested to hear some others opinions.

GMMAT 09-25-2008 08:32 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
I come up with 173-4/8" gross.

Awesome animal.

oakcreek 09-25-2008 08:37 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
154 gross

WakeCow 09-25-2008 08:39 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
Thats a nice deer. What county was he taken in?

HuntingBry 09-25-2008 08:43 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
I'm sure someone on here will say 120" because they didn't shoot it.[&:]

Here is my guesstimate:

R L
G16.5 6
G26.5 8
G3 88.5
G4 5.5 5.5
G5 2.5
H15.5 5.5
H2 5 5
H3 4.54.5
H44 4
Beams 22.523
Stickers 1.5 1.5

Sub 72 71.5

Spread 19

Total 162.5 Gross

He is a slammer of a buck. That is for sure.

cooter144 09-25-2008 08:57 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
I think some of you guys are underestimating the size of this one.

I have no doubt that deer has the overall height and beam length to score 170 plus.

Schultzy 09-25-2008 08:58 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
165"

Edcyclopedia 09-25-2008 09:05 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
160 ish'

GMMAT 09-25-2008 09:28 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
R L
G16.5 6
G26.5 8
G3 88.5
G4 5.5 5.5
G5 2.5
H15.5 5.5
H2 5 5
H3 4.54.5
H44 4
Beams 22.523
Stickers 1.5 1.5

Sub 72 71.5

Spread 19

Total 162.5 Gross

Bry:

I only "differ" with you "some" in the red areas. I also didn't even count the stickers. I think this deer WILL go over 170", though......easy.

Fun guessing;)

MN/Kyle 09-25-2008 09:48 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
Anyone ever heard the song

"In color" by Jamey Johnson? ;)

Excelent Deer! Taken in MN?

Schultzy 09-25-2008 09:51 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
Excelent Deer! Taken in MN?
They are here. Just not as many as there once was.

HuntingBry 09-25-2008 09:53 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: GMMAT

R L
G16.5 6
G26.5 8
G3 88.5
G4 5.5 5.5
G5 2.5
H15.5 5.5
H2 5 5
H3 4.54.5
H44 4
Beams 22.523
Stickers 1.5 1.5

Sub 72 71.5

Spread 19

Total 162.5 Gross

Bry:

I only "differ" with you "some" in the red areas. I also didn't even count the stickers. I think this deer WILL go over 170", though......easy.

Fun guessing;)
I wouldn't doubt it. I'm usually on the low side with estimates and when you get a deer that big a half inch short here and there adds up real fast.

MN/Kyle 09-25-2008 09:53 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: Schultzy

Excelent Deer! Taken in MN?
They are here. Just not as many as there once was.
Is this the point where we give a big shout out to the MN DNR? ;)

Schultzy 09-25-2008 09:55 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: MN/Kyle

ORIGINAL: Schultzy

Excelent Deer! Taken in MN?
They are here. Just not as many as there once was.
Is this the point where we give a big shout out to the MN DNR? ;)
That's a big 10-4 Kyle!!;)

minnesotadeer 09-25-2008 10:17 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
Kandiyohi county and its a hog. Andawesome for him. My mother-in-law works with his mother.I wasn't sure if I should post someone else's deer pic so that's why I just cropped it to show the deer.

But I was very interested in the potential score for curiousity sake and didn't want to call the guy to bug him. I don't even think he's probably scored it yet. There are nice deer in Minnesota, and who'da thunk, you don't even need to implement antler point restrictions. Just scout and hunt hard.

NCRemington700 09-25-2008 10:31 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: HuntingBry

I'm sure someone on here will say 120" because they didn't shoot it.[&:]
And who would that be??;):D

WWJD?!:D

Canuck33 09-25-2008 10:35 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
Definetely in the upper 150's into the 60's

Ben / PA 09-25-2008 10:58 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
All but break the 160 mark. I was near you Bry, but I don't think his mains are as long, but he has more mass than what you put down. Fun stuff, nice deer. Similar stickers to a "devil" buck that went down on last year's Dream Season I think?

Schultzy 09-25-2008 11:04 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: minnesotadeer

Kandiyohi county and its a hog. Andawesome for him. My mother-in-law works with his mother.I wasn't sure if I should post someone else's deer pic so that's why I just cropped it to show the deer.

But I was very interested in the potential score for curiousity sake and didn't want to call the guy to bug him. I don't even think he's probably scored it yet. There are nice deer in Minnesota, and who'da thunk, you don't even need to implement antler point restrictions. Just scout and hunt hard.
Wow, funny I never heard of this buck being shot. Kandiyohi county Is the next county west of me here In Meeker. I'll have to keep this buck In mind. A friend of mine Is a P&Y measurer that frequently stops out a few times a year to measure other peoples racks, wish more of them were mine![8D]

minnesotadeer 09-25-2008 11:06 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
You can see it in color at Pete's Surplus (intersection of Hwy 71 and Hwy 9). I believe it was taken not far from there west of New London. I thought it was a giant. I was just interested in what the score might be. Again, very cool and very good for him!

Schultzy 09-25-2008 11:23 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: minnesotadeer

You can see it in color at Pete's Surplus (intersection of Hwy 71 and Hwy 9). I believe it was taken not far from there west of New London. I thought it was a giant. I was just interested in what the score might be. Again, very cool and very good for him!
Thanks for the info minnesota!! I'll have to get a hold of this guy to see If he wants It officially scored. He's a brute, no doubt about that. The New London/Spicer area has some great bucks running around, great country around there!

triggertrav 09-25-2008 11:34 AM
RE: What would he score?
 
i would say about 177";)

turtleshell 09-25-2008 01:27 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: cooter144

I think some of you guys are underestimating the size of this one.

I have no doubt that deer has the overall height and beam length to score 170 plus.
No way.

my7pointmonster 09-25-2008 01:53 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
It looks like it was held really close to the camera aswell.

Ryan.

HuntingBry 09-25-2008 02:04 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: turtleshell

ORIGINAL: cooter144

I think some of you guys are underestimating the size of this one.

I have no doubt that deer has the overall height and beam length to score 170 plus.
No way.
OK, then what is your guess? I love it when guys come on these threads and say how wrong other people are but never post up a guess for themselves.[&:]

Oneshot7 09-25-2008 02:06 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
170's maybe 180sReal nice deer, great mass and spread with those long sweeping main beams, IDK how you guys are getting 150's

minnesotadeer 09-25-2008 02:08 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: my7pointmonster

It looks like it was held really close to the camera aswell.

Ryan.
Just interested, what would that have to do with anything? I'm assuming you mean like in pics where people stand or kneel way behind the deer or fish to make it look bigger but in this pic, the guy was practically side by side with it. I'm not debating score because I obviously don't really know how to do by looking at a pic yet, just saying the guy probably wasn't trying to make it look bigger. God knows its a beast as is.

NCRemington700 09-25-2008 02:11 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: HuntingBry

ORIGINAL: turtleshell

ORIGINAL: cooter144

I think some of you guys are underestimating the size of this one.

I have no doubt that deer has the overall height and beam length to score 170 plus.
No way.
OK, then what is your guess? I love it when guys come on these threads and say how wrong other people are but never post up a guess for themselves.[&:]
Now who would YOU be making fun of?!? :D

silentassassin 09-25-2008 02:15 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
170's maybe 180sReal nice deer, great mass and spread with those long sweeping main beams, IDK how you guys are getting 150's
I am certainly not trying to or meaning to deminish the deer. It's a great buck no matter what he scores. He just doesn't have great tine length and my first impression was a mid 150's buck. It's sounds like there is a decent chance of us finding out for sure what he does score and then we won't have to conjecture about it. Once again let me say for the record that I am no wiz at guessing scores so let me reitterate the fact that my misjudgement, if any, should not be mistaken for disrespect for the size of the animal.

cooter144 09-25-2008 03:46 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
ORIGINAL: turtleshell

ORIGINAL: cooter144

I think some of you guys are underestimating the size of this one.

I have no doubt that deer has the overall height and beam length to score 170 plus.
No way.
What do you think it is then?

My guestimates are below...why don't you show me yours?

R L
G17 6
G28 9
G39 9
G47 7
G53

H15 5
H24.54.5
H3 4.54.5
H44.54.5
Beams 24 24

Sub77.574.5

Spread 19

Total 171 Gross

Tim Boone 09-25-2008 04:14 PM
RE: What would he score?
 
150+ that's what dreams are made of.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:29 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.