RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Here is 125'' GROSS10 point measured by P & Y





129'' GROSS 8 point



10 point did not make P & Y net

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

If that's 135", I feel REALLY good about my guess, here.;)

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

I would not;)

He's not wide as mineand does not have the main beam length, he's a stud IMO. Looking at the two picture of him I still think he's 2.5;)

Mine has 17'' inside spread, this deer does not appear to be outside his ears. So he has a 14'' spread.

The only way to find out is for the poster to shoot him;)

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

OK....Granted...BUT:

He's got ya killed on G2's.
G3's are longer.
Right G4 is longer.

So...

Add

5" on G2's
3" on G3's
1" on Right G4

Subtract

4" on MB's
3" on Spread

I still have him at 135" +/-

You disagree? I think I'm being conservative on the adds/subtracts.

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Gary I'm going to have to disagree with you on the beam length. You've got him on spread, but the buck in the pics beams come around really well. It looks like there is only a 4 inch gap between the tips. Yours comes out but stops. The spread will help the beam length on yours, but I would guess that the main beams on buck in the pic are either as long or longer than yours.

Definitely not taking anything away from your buck. He's a stud fo sho.

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Poster shoot this big sob so we know:D BYW I made an edit, I cannot type either 125'' Gross on that top ten;) My bad Jeff S
Like I stated it's the beam length and spread IMO, but I know diddle:D







MB 21------21 2/8

G15 1/8----3 1/8
G2 7 3/8----8 2/8
G3 10 3/8---10 1/8
G4 ---------4 7/8

H1 3 7/8----4 1/8
H2 3 6/8----4
H3 3 7/8----4
H4 3 -------3 4/8

Inside spread16 1/8

137 6/8's Gross

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Here is a 134 3/8 gross scored by P&Y. This one only had a 15 1/2 inch spread.

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Coot great buck, he looks to be heavy on mass also. Our tens could be twins:D

BTW I love these pictures, it helps me in field judging

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

Thanks Germ. I can always use help on field judging too.

Seems like bucks I have shot ussually turn out to be a little bigger than I estimated from my stand.

I guess thats better than the opposite situation though...I just wonder if I have ever passed on any bucks that I probably should have shot?[&:]

RE: Will this PA 10 pt make P&Y???
 

I don't believe the ten in question will gross 135, but I do believe he will net pope.