HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/256371-gmmats-high-fence-thread.html)

AF Hunter 08-06-2008 11:03 AM

GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 
GMMAT's thread got me thinking and I did some quick research on the net. I wondered how many deer breeders and High Fence operations were in Iowa. I figured most of the folks here are down to earth hard working dirt famers. Much to my surprise, there are over 100 whitetail breeders and at least one high fence operation. One ranch was all I found listed, but I know there used to be several other "exotic hunting clubs" (that's what they called themselves) out there.

In the long term, what happens when one of these deer who were born, bred and lived all their life in captivity gets loose? Would they have the natural instinct to stay alive if they lived through the hunting season?

Schultzy 08-06-2008 11:07 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 

In the long term, what happens when one of these deer who were born, bred and lived all their life in captivity gets loose? Would they have the natural instinct to stay alive if they lived through the hunting season?
Not a chance!!!

PreacherTony 08-06-2008 11:10 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 

ORIGINAL: AF Hunter

GMMAT's thread got me thinking and I did some quick research on the net. I wondered how many deer breeders and High Fence operations were in Iowa. I figured most of the folks here are down to earth hard working dirt famers. Much to my surprise, there are over 100 whitetail breeders and at least one high fence operation. One ranch was all I found listed, but I know there used to be several other "exotic hunting clubs" (that's what they called themselves) out there.

In the long term, what happens when one of these deer who were born, bred and lived all their life in captivity gets loose? Would they have the natural instinct to stay alive if they lived through the hunting season?
I would think if they got loose during hunting season ....... bye bye

However, if after, I bet they would follow the local deer herd and eat what they eat ..... maybe they would hang around the high fence .......who knows .....

HuntingBry 08-06-2008 11:15 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 
I was talking to Pabuckbuster12 and he knows a deer farmer who lost a bunch of deer one season. He called the PGC and asked if he could recover them. They told him once the deer were off his property they belonged to the PGC. He then asked if that was the case if one of his deer with his tags in the ear were hit by a car the PGC assumed any and all liability. They said no, he was liable.[&:]

The long and the short someone smacked one of his bucks during gun season that scored in the 190's and still had his tags in the ear. The PGC allowed it to qualify in the state record books.[:@]

jmbuckhunter 08-06-2008 11:20 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 

ORIGINAL: AF Hunter

what happens when one of these deer who were born, bred and lived all their life in captivity gets loose?
They spread CWD and all the other diseases captive deer get to the native herd.[:'(][:@][&:]:(

robbcayman 08-06-2008 11:25 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 
Trust me, these guys have too much money into to allow them to get loose. However, if that did occur, I think they would survive.

I mean, how hard is it to eat acorns and drink water? ;)

OHbowhntr 08-06-2008 11:34 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 

ORIGINAL: HuntingBry

I was talking to Pabuckbuster12 and he knows a deer farmer who lost a bunch of deer one season. He called the PGC and asked if he could recover them. They told him once the deer were off his property they belonged to the PGC. He then asked if that was the case if one of his deer with his tags in the ear were hit by a car the PGC assumed any and all liability. They said no, he was liable.[&:]

The long and the short someone smacked one of his bucks during gun season that scored in the 190's and still had his tags in the ear. The PGC allowed it to qualify in the state record books.[:@]
Both THIS and THIS do not surprise me at all. It's all GOOD for them and NO GOOD for him. But if he had "Business Insurance," he should have been able to be re-imbursed for the animals lost, shouldn't he???

In the long term, I agree that during deer season, they'd get WHACKED, and likely in a hurry. Off season, I'm still thinking they'd end up getting WHACKED more quickly than an animal that had been "Free" all of it's life.


LouisianaTomkat 08-06-2008 11:35 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 
How hard would it be to offer him a handful of corn and put an arrow thru him?:eek:

JNTURK 08-06-2008 11:50 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 

ORIGINAL: OHbowhntr


ORIGINAL: HuntingBry

I was talking to Pabuckbuster12 and he knows a deer farmer who lost a bunch of deer one season. He called the PGC and asked if he could recover them. They told him once the deer were off his property they belonged to the PGC. He then asked if that was the case if one of his deer with his tags in the ear were hit by a car the PGC assumed any and all liability. They said no, he was liable.[&:]

The long and the short someone smacked one of his bucks during gun season that scored in the 190's and still had his tags in the ear. The PGC allowed it to qualify in the state record books.[:@]
Both THIS and THIS do not surprise me at all. It's all GOOD for them and NO GOOD for him. But if he had "Business Insurance," he should have been able to be re-imbursed for the animals lost, shouldn't he???

In the long term, I agree that during deer season, they'd get WHACKED, and likely in a hurry. Off season, I'm still thinking they'd end up getting WHACKED more quickly than an animal that had been "Free" all of it's life.
yes and no.. it would have to be a "special" policy written with special terms and conditions. only a few carriers, to my knowledge, could write up something like that...but it is possible, he would be paying a pretty penny for a policy like that

Mike from Texas 08-06-2008 11:55 AM

RE: GMMAT'S HIGH FENCE THREAD
 
Ignorance is truly bliss.:eek:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:31 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.