P & Y scoring question....
 

When figuring up deductions, are they figured side to side or point to point?

On my buck, if I go by total inches of the right side vs. the left, he has 1 7/8......If I compare point to point, he's got a little over 5....

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Deleted for skirting the profanity filter.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

I believe its side to side Don. That way main beam length is figured in. Killer buck bro! ;)

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Its point to point Mo.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

I could be wrong :D

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Point to point mobow. Eample would be- (G1 to G1 and so on) (MB to MB) H1 to H1 and so on)

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Mobow: go to this website, it'll help: http://www.minnesotabucks.com/score%20sheet.htm

It'll automatically score it for you.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Thx AF I used that on last years buck

I got 0 deductions, I scored Gross0and 0 Net, damn it[8D]

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

That's what I thought. Bummer. I just don't think he's gonna make it then, but I'll score him anyway. He's kind of strange....His left side G1 is longer, his right side G2 is longer, his left side G3 is longer, and his right side MB is longer.....Mass is damn near the same....

Side to side I came up w/ 1 7/8, but point to point I came up with 4 1/8...Kinda strange, huh?

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

I don't care who you are, that there is FUNNY!:)

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Not strange at all. 4 1/8 deductions is pretty good and symmetrical. Well below the average.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Ha ha, after reading it, mine could be taken as wrong also!
You actually have 4 columns that get added and subtracted.
1. Is spread credit or inside spread.
2. Is right side, length of main beam, then G, then H
3. Is left side, same as above
4. Is differences
when your all done scoring, you add column 1,2 and 3then subtract the differences.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Mine looked just like yours, Twins!

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Thought of you yesterday as I passed the pink elephant, I was in Garland golfing[8D] I did not see one dang deer

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Seen 2 Monsters about 3 miles south of there a few years ago comming back from hunting by Black River. Told the wife we were hunting the wrong place!
Should have stoped by we only live 8miles out of town.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

I will next time, should be back in October.
I still have not seen a damn Elk either[&:]

We will talk about P & Y scoring system

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

HIJAKCERS!! :D:D

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Mobow I edited my post to stay on topic

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Well if you get back up in mid to late Sept to do any scouting on the buck of the shed you found, we will take a ride upby Black River and I will call a few Bulls in with a turkey call and golf bag club tube for you to get a close look at.
Looks like were going to be in Maryland working/hunting the whole month of Oct, then on to KY for the first 10 days of Nov, then Kansas till next spring.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Don, sent you the Excel worksheets for typical and non typical. If they work good for you and you want to share, feel free to do so.

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

yea its point to point not side to side

RE: P & Y scoring question....
 

Sorry Mo, Back on topic. 4 1/8 is great for deductions, Killed a big 10 in MI back in the 80's that had over 140" of bone on its head, had about a 2" differnce in beam length and just about a 2" differnce on every tine on its head, jumping from one side to the other, lostaround 20'' on him, still a great buck , just didn't score for crap.