HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/241239-would-concern-you-if-you-were-passing-bucks.html)

HuntingBry 04-07-2008 01:52 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: bawanajim


ORIGINAL: Schultzy


ORIGINAL: GMMAT

Let me ask another question....

Could crop rotation have anything to do with this phenomenon?
Deffinately can have an effect!
Another reason to plant your own field with the proper forage.;)
But, isn't that baiting.;)

bawanajim 04-07-2008 01:53 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 
I'm a baiter, just not very good at it ..............yet.[:o]

GregH 04-07-2008 01:55 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: bawanajim

I'm a baiter, just not very good at it ..............yet.[:o]
You know you're a Master.......... [:-]

bawanajim 04-07-2008 02:00 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: GregH


ORIGINAL: bawanajim

I'm a baiter, just not very good at it ..............yet.[:o]
You know you're a Master.......... [:-]
The list of things in life I've mastered is a long one.;)


But baiting at that levelaways seemsjust out of hand.[8D]

Oneshot7 04-07-2008 02:01 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: GMMAT


Alot of these younger bucks take to new areas the following year I believe.
I agree that a lot of these little guys have ever expanding home ranges.....but it would make sense if they were replaced with other deer of the same age structure,........wouldn't it?

If this is the case (they disperse and have larger ranges than their older counterparts).....doesn't it make passing on them futile? I mean....I have no desire to kill these juveniles.....but I can see where people might take a different approach if they thought they were going to disperse from their properties, anyways.

Interesting.....ya gotta admit.....to not even see ONE of them.
The bull was there until you shot him, therefore he pushed most of them out of the area with his dominance, and made them go nocturnal. Now that the bull is gone I would imagine one of them will step up to take his role of dominance.

GMMAT 04-07-2008 02:02 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

The bull was there until you shot him, therefore he pushed most of them out of the area with his dominance, and made them go nocturnal. Now that the bull is gone I would imagine one of them will step up to take his role of dominance.
I don't know ANYTHING about such.....but I've thought this way, too. I hope you're right.;)

kwilson16 04-07-2008 02:04 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 
Crop rotation and harvest time frame have a dramatic effect in Eastern NC and WV. In NC, they pick the corn in August/Sept and it has little effect on the deer hunting thereafter. The beans are picked later and they create a major food source for deer during the NC season.Another example, if the corn is unpicked in WV, you can bet many of the deer are holed-up in the cornfields. If it is picked just a day or two before season, the hunting is improved as the deer disperse.

Jeff - If crop rotation is the answer toyour mystery, you should be able to sort through by re-examining field usage over the preceding years. Your harvest times and subsequent effects might be a lot different than mine. Do you have dog hunting there? Thoseclowns cancompletely disrupt an area ... pretty quick too.

GregH 04-07-2008 02:07 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: bawanajim


ORIGINAL: GregH


ORIGINAL: bawanajim

I'm a baiter, just not very good at it ..............yet.[:o]
You know you're a Master.......... [:-]
The list of things in life I've mastered is a long one.;)


But baiting at that levelaways seemsjust out of hand.[8D]
I always thought a Master had things in hand!!

RockinChair 04-07-2008 02:08 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 

ORIGINAL: Oneshot7


ORIGINAL: GMMAT


Alot of these younger bucks take to new areas the following year I believe.
I agree that a lot of these little guys have ever expanding home ranges.....but it would make sense if they were replaced with other deer of the same age structure,........wouldn't it?

If this is the case (they disperse and have larger ranges than their older counterparts).....doesn't it make passing on them futile? I mean....I have no desire to kill these juveniles.....but I can see where people might take a different approach if they thought they were going to disperse from their properties, anyways.

Interesting.....ya gotta admit.....to not even see ONE of them.
The bull was there until you shot him, therefore he pushed most of them out of the area with his dominance, and made them go nocturnal. Now that the bull is gone I would imagine one of them will step up to take his role of dominance.
I wouldnt think that one dominant buck would push several subordinate bucks all the way out of the area?

gutshot 04-07-2008 02:10 PM

RE: Would it concern you if you were passing on bucks?
 
Jeff I would agree that your bucks that you killed so far were the dominant bucks for your area and probably have pushed the smaller bucks out. But I also think that from what you have discribe you hunt in a urban setting and I think that urban buckschange their travel patterns as their surroundings change like new sub divisions and new construction comes in. JMO


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:52 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.