HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Bowhunting (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting-18/)
-   -   What do rounded tine tips mean? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/bowhunting/236170-what-do-rounded-tine-tips-mean.html)

Hoytail Hunter 03-06-2008 07:57 PM

What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
I have a 144" that I shot many years ago with my 270. I guess him to be 3 1/2 yrs old. The tips of his tines are sharp and pointed.

I have a another buck that I shot this year with my bow that I just got back from the taxi. I guessed him to be 4 1/2. Now I'm reconsideringthat he might be olderafter a conversation I had with a fellow employee. He said rounded tips mean that the deer is passed prime. Prime is about 6 yrs right? I know nothing of this. Does anyone?

Rory/MO 03-06-2008 07:59 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
hm. ive never heard that. i dont really think its true, but it may be. im not sure

TEmbry 03-06-2008 08:01 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
Are you talkin acorn tips, where they mushroom back down torward the tine? Similar to a bullet after flight?

If so, those are neat looking deer, but I think i read in D&DH mag that it is just another abnormality, kinda like a droptine or kicker point. They seem to be more rare though, because I hardly ever see pics of deer with acorn tips.

Rory/MO 03-06-2008 08:05 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

ORIGINAL: TEmbry

Are you talkin acorn tips, where they mushroom back down torward the tine? Similar to a bullet after flight?

If so, those are neat looking deer, but I think i read in D&DH mag that it is just another abnormality, kinda like a droptine or kicker point. They seem to be more rare though, because I hardly ever see pics of deer with acorn tips.
i almost shot one this fall! he was a 4.5 im pretty sure, but deffinitely met my standards. he was at least a 140" deer. if i would have cleared the shooting lane 10 yards further i woulda killed him. very neat to see him

Hoytail Hunter 03-06-2008 08:06 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
No, not acorn tips. These tips are rounded justlike your fingertips. There's no point to any of them.

TEmbry 03-06-2008 08:09 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
hmmm, makes sense to be an older deer, but maybe just variety to the racks? IDK man.[&:] I have noticed that it makes the racks look more massive when they have the old rounded tips.

KansasBBD 03-06-2008 08:13 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

ORIGINAL: TEmbry

Are you talkin acorn tips, where they mushroom back down torward the tine? Similar to a bullet after flight?

If so, those are neat looking deer, but I think i read in D&DH mag that it is just another abnormality, kinda like a droptine or kicker point. They seem to be more rare though, because I hardly ever see pics of deer with acorn tips.
any pics of this? ive never seen it.

Hoytail Hunter 03-06-2008 08:18 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
Also, the distance between the bases where the browtines start are a whole inch wider on the rounded tips buck. Would this suggest he is much older?

He also has an H1 mass of 5" whereas the other is only about 4 1/4. Well they did come out of different habitats so I guess that really don't mean much.

lnen#1 03-06-2008 10:01 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
He did too much of this with his antlers
<------

125py 03-07-2008 08:00 AM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
i would say there is no truth in that

Rory/MO 03-07-2008 08:05 AM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

He did too much of this with his antlers
<------
:D

wallhangr 03-07-2008 08:20 AM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

ORIGINAL: KansasBBD


ORIGINAL: TEmbry

Are you talkin acorn tips, where they mushroom back down torward the tine? Similar to a bullet after flight?

If so, those are neat looking deer, but I think i read in D&DH mag that it is just another abnormality, kinda like a droptine or kicker point. They seem to be more rare though, because I hardly ever see pics of deer with acorn tips.
any pics of this? ive never seen it.

I've got one on the wall at home, I'll have to try and get a pic to show you. The ends of the main beams are both like that.

TEmbry 03-07-2008 09:25 AM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

ORIGINAL: wallhangr


ORIGINAL: KansasBBD


ORIGINAL: TEmbry

Are you talkin acorn tips, where they mushroom back down torward the tine? Similar to a bullet after flight?

If so, those are neat looking deer, but I think i read in D&DH mag that it is just another abnormality, kinda like a droptine or kicker point. They seem to be more rare though, because I hardly ever see pics of deer with acorn tips.
any pics of this? ive never seen it.

I've got one on the wall at home, I'll have to try and get a pic to show you. The ends of the main beams are both like that.

be great dude, i looked forever online to no avail. I think I saw it on the TV show the more I think about it, IDK but these racks are pretty sweet looking, definitely unique.

Jawshooter 03-07-2008 12:10 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
Rounded tips canhappen fora variety of reasons. Like others said could be genitics. Alot of times deer will chip the ends of their tines and thru normal wear and tear they become rounded. another possiblility is that the deer just wasnt fininsh growing this antlers before the velvet was shed. Most times the antler are fully developed when the tips become pointed under the velvet but in certain instances the burr cuts off blood supply before the tips finish growing...which leads to rounded tips. Really has nothing to do with age.

HuntingBry 03-07-2008 01:54 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 

ORIGINAL: Jawshooter

Rounded tips canhappen fora variety of reasons. Like others said could be genitics. Alot of times deer will chip the ends of their tines and thru normal wear and tear they become rounded. another possiblility is that the deer just wasnt fininsh growing this antlers before the velvet was shed. Most times the antler are fully developed when the tips become pointed under the velvet but in certain instances the burr cuts off blood supply before the tips finish growing...which leads to rounded tips. Really has nothing to do with age.
This I believe. A buddy of mine shot a 2.5 year old 9 point this year and all of his tips were rounded. We tried to figure it out and he suggested that they were damaged in velvet, but I couldn't see every tip on both antlers being damaged. The velvet coming off before the tips harden definitely makes sense.

MeanV2 03-07-2008 02:25 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
It's either genetics or the velvet coming off premature. I doubt it has anything to do with age or you see it on older bucks more often.

Dan

Hoytail Hunter 03-07-2008 05:19 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
Thanks, I guess the guy was talking 'cause he could, not 'cause he knew. And I didn't refute 'cause I didn't know but now I do. cool cool.

Schultzy 03-07-2008 05:30 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
I would say It had something to do with that velvet coming off premature or possibly even this buck did a pile of rubbing on tree's. Was it just the end of the main beams? All the tines? G1's? Abnormal points?

Hoytail Hunter 03-07-2008 06:49 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
Every single point on this 10 is that way. The browtines are not as rounded though. I'm convinced now, it's probably genetics. I just don't see excessive rubbing on trees making for such perfect fingertip round points.

Jawshooter 03-07-2008 09:47 PM

RE: What do rounded tine tips mean?
 
actually hoytail that is a perfect examle ofa rack that wasnt completly finished growing! Browtines are closest to theburr hence they would be the ones the are closest to being fully developed at the tips. all tips will be blunt in this type of case. Does the rack haveblunt tips like this pic? More blunted? less? This rack is a result of not having fully developed before the burr shut off blood supply, leaving the tips under developed.
*notice the brow is more developed compared to the other tines






All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:13 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.