How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

Just curious here. I let several go in the 2006 season that I didn't even see this year.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

I killed a nice 3 1/2 year old buck last year that I had let walk the last day of season the prior year.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

I had 44 buck SIGHTINGS in 2006.

I had SEVEN buck sightings in 2007.

I've killed bucks I've seen, before.....but I've yet to let one walk one year and see him the next. If I'd had a chance to shoot the one I shot this year.....last year....I'd have tried to kill him. The other buck I took, this year, was a BB, last year.....for sure. I didn't see more than 4 different bucks, this entire season.....in 48 sits.

I "passed" on 15-17 1.5yr olds in '06....only to see ZERO of them, this past year.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

I haven't shot one that I've seen before, but the past 2 seasons I have seen the same buck and let him walk both times. But if he comes back next year.....

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

It's too hard for me to tell. Since I am only able to take 2.5 year old bucks (the older ones just don't exist around me), it's too hard to tell if it was the same buck as the year before. When bucks are button bucks, there's no way of telling what their antlers are going to look like when they are 1.5 and no way of telling they are the same deer from year to year (unless there is some sort of physical marking). The same goes for when the bucks are 1.5. They could range from spikes to small 8 or 10 points...but you never know what they are going to look like the next year. So much can change. Now...if there were some older bucks around my highly pressured area, I'm sure it would be easy to tell the same buck at 2.5, 3.5, and 4.5 years old.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

Just once. There was a sickly looking, small 3 point buck on one of the farms I hunt. The next year he was still there, cant miss his little frame and sickly walk. We has still3 points but he had nice mass.:D Last week of the season he came by me and I still had a buck tag so I took him.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

Mr. Java let one walk ; nice wide one.. was a small six the first year he saw him. Same buck came by following year..
6 pt to 8 pt
1" brows to approx 4"
15" wide to 20" wide

Nice one.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

I have no idea. I pass and pass and pass some more and I always wonder if any of the 3.5's I've taken or the 4.5 I missed are bucks I've passed before. I never recognize them as previous sighted bucks. Problem with PA, the one I pass probably get shot, at least I'm trying.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

Same like Rob, I would have no way of knowing what the young bucks I pass on turn out to be.

RE: How many have killed a buck they let walk in prior seasons?
 

I passed on a 14" 8 point last year that was a young buck. He got hit by a car in August. Had a real nice rack at that point.