Fight or broad head.....
 

I took this pic of this little scub buck this morning... He's got a huge gash on his back...

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

you shot him right?

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

a....NO[:-]...way to little son...

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

broadhead for sure.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

when you see a wounded animal you take him, I dont care if he is small you take him out like a responcible hunter.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

LOL! Jim, He will recover from that just fine! Thats merely a flesh wound.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

Hes got a scratch on his back and you think the guy should kill it. Jim, Jim, Jim. You need to get a grip on something besides your chicken.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

Yeah what ever dude...The buck was perfectly fine...There's NO way im puttin my tag on thatbuck.. Now maybe if couldnt walk or something.. I may have..I rattled him in around 10:30...

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

I did that to a doe last year. Exactly what that looks like...then I saw her two weeks later with a healed scratch and trying to advoid the buck chasing her.

Paul

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

This is starting to get to me. Why do people think that b/c a deer is wounded it will die???? Deer heal just like we do except they don't go to the hosp. for care. Deer will eat certain foods when they are injured too. They can get better. I had a guy bring me his doe in late sept that he shot during archery season. Judging by the lookof the hind leg it had been broken. It looked strange...... but it had healed. It appeared that the bone had a bulge all around it so I would figure that b/c the leg wasn't immobilized it had a hard time setting in the correct spot. But it healed on its own. We are not GOD's, we are hunters.
The deer might have less chance of survival but its not dead. Unless it looks like the deer is suffering I let'em walk. And remember suffering is a relative term.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

maybe if jim gets a scratch someone should put him down

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

also as smallas he is i cannot see whay someone was shooting at him in the first place

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

ahh mabey it was a new hunter. Nervous about his first buck and was a little shaky. He prob moved the bow up to see the shot. And well with any luck mabey natural selection will have its way with you bigtim6656. We all have dreams.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

Before we give Jim too much grief he has a point, somewhat. A big factor in whether that deer will heal or not is how warm it is as far as flies and bacteria goes. I know here is PA it has been very warm for the time of year and I would be skeptical as to whether that wouldheal or not. I don't know the weatherin NY so he may heal or he may not. If I thought he would not heal then I would shoot him (in this case he wouldn't be legal for me to shoot in PA, 3 point rule).

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

[
You need to get a grip on something besides your chicken.
[/quote]


Now thats funny.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

Could have been anything. Fence or another buck gets my vote. Doesn't look like a BH cut b/c if you look at it, its not a straight cut.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

if you put it out of his misery it has 0% chance of recovery....

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

looks like a broadhead to me.


With all the Rage rage, I'm betting on a Rage 2 blade, lol any takers? ;)


Looks like he pegged you with the camera out, nasty looking wound though. Looks like he could have used some stitches and pain killers.[8D]

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

I dunno............. GMMAT woulda smoked him.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

Muckland,

Are there any barbwire fences around?? I once watched a doe try to duck under one and tore her back open pretty good...looked alot like that.

RE: Fight or broad head.....
 

LOL:D
Thats a good one motown!