Would you take this buck
 

Attached are two pics from my stealth cam. What do you think the weight, score and age could possibly be. And most of all would you take this deer out of the herd.

RE: Would you take this buck
 

Here is another picture a little closer up.

RE: Would you take this buck
 

I could only answer that when he stood in front of me. In the first photo he looks good, in the second he looks weak. Looks like he's missing brow points...I'd like to say I'd give him another year, the moment of truth would make me decide one way or another.

RE: Would you take this buck
 

I hunt blacktails and one like that is defenitly a shooter!

RE: Would you take this buck
 

weight is around 180, score is around 115ish and age is around 3 1/2... I would take this buck if it was in my stand but whatever makes you feel good do it!

RE: Would you take this buck
 

its a bit hard to tell but it looks like a nice mature deer. If i saw him under my stand it would be hard to pass up thats for sure!

RE: Would you take this buck
 

Looks like it might be two different deer in the pics.

RE: Would you take this buck
 

i'd take him in a heartbeat!

RE: Would you take this buck
 

Would I take that deer in MY woods, yes.

RE: Would you take this buck
 

BBD in my book