Would you take this buck
#31

That is def. the same buck. And if that buck walked by in my area I would pass on him. That wouldn't be much of a buck here in west central IL. Maybe in a year or two.

#33

That is def. the same buck.

#37

I wouldn't shoot him but thats just the way i manage the woods i hunt. If you want him more power to you, thats all up to you! Looks to me he'd score about 105 and weighs about 160lbs. Looks to be a 3.5 year old. Good luck with whatever you decide to do!