Test
 

Test 180 class whitetail with your rifle or a 150 class with your bow? Things we do when we sit all day ?????

RE: Test
 

the one with a bow I do not like guns for hunting IMHO

RE: Test
 

Tough one....i dont gun hunt, but i would like a 180!!:D

RE: Test
 

Whichever I have when I see 180 class buck. Hell I'd try with a slingshot!

RE: Test
 

I'd like to just SEE, EITHER!

RE: Test
 

I'd rather shoot the 150 with a bow than a 180 with a rifle, that's just me, ya'll can make your own choice.;)

RE: Test
 

The 150 w/ a bow would be just fine. I've never seen a 120 in the PA woods I hunt.

RE: Test
 

I would take either one.

RE: Test
 

I would love to see either in the woods, but that would be something to have a 150" within bow range!!!!!!!

RE: Test
 

Both, but I'm just that good.

RE: Test
 

Ditto. I just enjoy bowhunting that much more, and the end result isn't my number one reason for hunting.

RE: Test
 

Would love to see either but will choose the 150 class with my bow!!

RE: Test
 

180 with a gun here ......

RE: Test
 

150 with a bow.

RE: Test
 

Look at my avatar,I did not take it and it was taken with a gun.



I would have to say a 150 with a bow,if I were to see a 180 while gun hunting,I would have to explain the smell and stains on my clothes when I got back to camp.[:o]

RE: Test
 

well i have seen a 150 in bow range and a 180 in gun range and i would have shot sither actually i did shoot the 1250 but high shoulder shot and he is still alive

RE: Test
 

Now that would be a new record :D

RE: Test
 

They both sound good to me!:)

RE: Test
 

LOL! :D:D:D

RE: Test
 

heck yea t fox as you could imagine i was so upset with myself LOL:D
correction 150

RE: Test
 

Anything with my bow is better than shooting one with my gun. I'll take the 150 also.

RE: Test
 

I'd rather see the 150 through my bow sight at 25yds, than the 180 through my scope at 150yds. I'm not knocking guns, I have multiple. Getting close is what counts for me. I think it's more of a challange.

RE: Test
 

I'm shootin the one w/ the bow.....I think.....[&:]

RE: Test
 

Well ya see, you're assuming that 150 or 180 means something to us. I don't measure deer. I just weigh them.... sometimes. I don't care if I ever shoot another deer with a gun. But I'd shoot a doe in a heart beat with my bow. I surely wouldn't worry about a few inches of horn. I'm a bow hunter. I'll shoot what I want and can and don't concern myself with what might have been if I'd had a gun. I'd rather shoot your 150 with a bow than a 220 with a gun. I just live to bowhunt. I don't care what the score is.

RE: Test
 

This should be nominated for "best post"!! I will be giggling all night!

RE: Test
 

Tell you the truth, he doesn't even have to be 150 and I'll take him over a 180 with a gun.My dinky 50 inch 6 pointer took more effort, energy, resources, planning, etc. etc. than my 143 inch9 pointer hanging on my wall by way of .270 Remington.

As long as he is 2.5 yrs old I'd feel more of a sense of accomplishment than taking his 180 class father with a long range missle.

RE: Test
 

Both... might as well be greedy.

My biggest buck is with bow although not a 180. I ambushed him at 12 yards. Scouting payed off.


My biggest rifle buckwas shotabout 20 yards after a 3/4 - 1 mile stalk. Tyler was with me every step of the way.

Which am I more proud of ?? Hard to say as both were great hunts for different reasons. The weapon didn't make the hunt since both bucks would have died with either... the hunt itself always is the most important. I like to hunt and I likegetting close no matter the weapon. While I enjoy bowhunting more then rifle hunting...the hunt is what matters the most to me.

Tim

RE: Test
 

I would be happy making the minimum 125 with my bow, for a Typical Pope and Young Whitetail.

RE: Test
 

I would have to say the 150 with a bow. I'm a bowhunter at heart, and gun hunt to spend time with friends. Although to see either would be nice.

RE: Test
 

no kidding!

RE: Test
 

probably a 150 w/ bow, but I also have never seen anything close to this in the public woods I hunt.

RE: Test
 

I would have to say either, i would say i do 95% of my hunting with the bow and prefer bow over gun, but whatever keeps me in the woods is what i will do. Either one better be careful if he walks in my woods!

RE: Test
 

would have to take the 150 with a bow, but i would probly miss....lol

RE: Test
 

Heck, I'd be happy to shoot a 150 with a gun!