none
11-10-2006, 07:41 PM
#11
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Stony Point/Albany, NY
Posts: 1,479
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: jelen
No Richard...I'm quite clear about his post...and as far as I can see he doesn't have a single fact correct exempt his default username...once he does have ANYthing correct he is free to post it...but last I heard it was a Pennsylvania buck and if the poster is clear about things he could certainly agree...given a lick of sense.
ORIGINAL: solocamcan
You need to re-read his post Mr. Obvious, he said Kansas not Penn.
You need to re-read his post Mr. Obvious, he said Kansas not Penn.
11-10-2006, 07:50 PM
#12
Spike
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Stevens Point WI USA
Posts: 75
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: jelen
No Richard...I'm quite clear about his post...and as far as I can see he doesn't have a single fact correct exempt his default username...once he does have ANYthing correct he is free to post it...but last I heard it was a Pennsylvania buck and if the poster is clear about things he could certainly agree...given a lick of sense.
ORIGINAL: solocamcan
You need to re-read his post Mr. Obvious, he said Kansas not Penn.
You need to re-read his post Mr. Obvious, he said Kansas not Penn.
11-10-2006, 07:53 PM
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location:
Posts: 3,465
RE: world record deer??
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
11-10-2006, 08:44 PM
#15
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location:
Posts: 81
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: solocamcan
My mistake jelen, I doubt serioslly that world record would ever come out of Penn. anyways. And we ALL agree, by seasons end there will be at least 3 other "world record" deer taken.
My mistake jelen, I doubt serioslly that world record would ever come out of Penn. anyways. And we ALL agree, by seasons end there will be at least 3 other "world record" deer taken.
11-10-2006, 09:00 PM
#17
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location:
Posts: 62
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: TEmbry15
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
) So if the amish buck is a state record then I would have to say it is a world record, but beaty's buck went over 300 inches.
11-10-2006, 09:04 PM
#18
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location:
Posts: 81
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: scsohunter
As far as I know the world record buck is from ohio. It was killed by Mike Beaty in Greene county (about 30-45 min. away) So if the amish buck is a state record then I would have to say it is a world record, but beaty's buck went over 300 inches.
ORIGINAL: TEmbry15
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
) So if the amish buck is a state record then I would have to say it is a world record, but beaty's buck went over 300 inches.
11-10-2006, 09:15 PM
#19
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location:
Posts: 62
RE: world record deer??
ORIGINAL: jelen
I heard after re-scoring that the Amish buck went 9.125 inches over Beatty??? Keep chasin' the tape and you'll lose your passion.
ORIGINAL: scsohunter
As far as I know the world record buck is from ohio. It was killed by Mike Beaty in Greene county (about 30-45 min. away) So if the amish buck is a state record then I would have to say it is a world record, but beaty's buck went over 300 inches.
ORIGINAL: TEmbry15
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
if he SAW a huge deer then why would you say he has nothing correct. and come on, do you honestly think pennsylvania has the genetics for a world record deer? there have been some monster deer taken already this year including the KY monster and the 295 inch deer taken by an amish fella in Ohio. it is the state record for ohio and only 13 inches shy of being the biggest buck ever taken by a hunter. and there was the huge high fence deer killed at Timberghost in Iowa that will make the #1 SCI typical. so monsters have been taken this year, and many will come from kansas. i believe he saw a MONSTER f oa deer, though i doubt it is close to a world record or it would be in the news and onthe web everywhere.DONT TELL SOMEONE WHAT THEY SAW!
) So if the amish buck is a state record then I would have to say it is a world record, but beaty's buck went over 300 inches.
