atlasman

I love how stories like this one just get brushed under the rug in threads like this. Why is it that people who swear by the benefits of carbon use isolated deer encounters in the woods as proof of that products value and effectiveness..........yet whenever someone says they accomplished the EXACT same thing without carbon they don't treat it with the same respect.

Here is a guy offering valuable tools that could help people actually UNDERSTAND something more about scent control.............but some are more interested in hearing "I put on a suit and saw a deer downwind"



Weird.

atlasman

You killed P+Y bucks with and without carbon suits.......so how did it help you??


How does it work then??.......if it adsorbs odors as well as advertised you shouldn't have to be scent free to put it on.


If you practice strict scent control then why do you need a suit?


Were you not happy with the P+Y bucks you killed before carbon suits?

Justin

On the flip side of this - Todd (The Lone Wolf's) wind might not have been reaching this deer like he thought it was due to thermals. So maybe his encounter w/o scent control clothing isn't reliable either!



Edit: If I hear one more arguement about this I'm gonna puke. How many time are we going to cover the same topic over and over and over?? If you believe in it, great. If not, that's great too. Why do we keep chasing our tails on this?

Atlasman - WE GET YOUR POINT ALREADY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!

Germ

Atlas two more days and you get to hunt, looks like a great opening day for you.

Go practice up and get ready, and have a great season.

By chance do you know where i can find one of those magic rocks?

mrfritz44

I'll be damned if I buy camo clothes that cost more than what I work in............

There are better and cheaper ways to go scent free.

isatarak

I started using VooDoo this year and I've already killed a nice doe and a nice 10-point. With VooDoo you don't have to worry about whether the rock is lucky or not. Nothing is left to chance.

kevin1

I've got a driveway chock full of them , stop by and take your pick .
While you'here , I've got a chemical protective suit that's new in package left over , you can have it along with the used one I also have , just reactivate it and forget that pesky ol' wind ...

MichaelT.

Gee I thought this thread was about one guys hunting experience....

But It is about scent - lok suits , magic rocks, and voodoo...LOL

I sure am glad no one has come out on here telling everyone how much better Matthews Bows are than Botech Bows. Or, talking about how much smoother and quieter they are. Or more well made. Yep, I sure am glad that hasn't happened...LOL

statjunk

When I posted on another carbon suit post last time someone asked me why do I care so much that so many hunters are wasting their money on this clothes and I said that I don't. I realized the other day that I do. I was at Bass Pro looking to get a set of Under Armor to stay warm. The sales guy kept pushing the Scent-Lok version of the Under Armor saying it was the best they had in the store and it would make me see more deer (He actually said this). When I told him that I wasn't interested in anything scent lok he proceeded to tell me all the testimonials. I felt ill and just walked away from him and when he followed me I told him to go help another customer.

Clearly the marketing for this clothing has reached the level of DeBeers the Diamond company. In Japan they never used to use diamond rings to get married now they do and women are beginning to consider it insulting if they don't get one. Just like a lot of folks getting into hunting believe that you can't hunt without the magic suit. I was one of those people and if I can stop a few people from making the same mistake I did that would be good.

Atlasman, you're doing the right thing.

Tom