guesses on score
 

i just don't know if i what to shoot this deer. I would like some guesses on score. thanks

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i264/ilbowhunter88/buckgood86.jpg

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i264/ilbowhunter88/buckgood83.jpg

RE: guesses on score
 

hmmm, I'd pass on him. Probably only bout 100" Hes a nice 2.5 yr old. Next yr he'll be real nice.

RE: guesses on score
 

He will not make 110" . No

RE: guesses on score
 

not real big, might break 100 but if it would be your biggest I wouldn't hesitate.

RE: guesses on score
 

similar to a 6 i killed last year..no more than 105

RE: guesses on score
 

I would say 90-100

RE: guesses on score
 

I would say pass hes pretty good, but next year he will be even bigger and a better trophy to hang on the wall.

RE: guesses on score
 

I'd agree with most everyone...probably right on the 100 mark. Good deer to let mature and see what he may become. Good luck.


Red

RE: guesses on score
 

id say about 100 also......

about taking him or not its allllll upto you..just because these guys wouldnt shoot him i for one would in a heartbeat. to me that would be a decint nice buck......and my biggest.....and my first with a bow...this is my first year bowhunting..im trying to contain myself....but anything legal(4pts to a side) and im not going to lie..first day..first light i dont care im drawing. im going to TRY to hang in there unless its pretty decint until a little later.....but i doubt i can. i hunt public land..or open private land. for me to pass a legal buck would mean im GIVING it to someone else pretty much. someone here said never pass a buck the first day that you would shoot the last day....thats going to be my new motto...because tomarrow may never come for a legal buck around here atleast...all depends on the situation...but for me this year id take him. but thats a decision you gotta make....

RE: guesses on score
 

Im going to say near 100 but not quite. Still a fine buck.

RE: guesses on score
 

Id let um walk 1 more year. but its all up 2 u....good luck

RE: guesses on score
 

I would give him another year or two.

RE: guesses on score
 

I doubt he would make the 100" mark. He should be pretty nice if he makes it till next year. They don't grow very much in the freezer.

RE: guesses on score
 

well if youre not after antlers which you cant eat anyway, id say take him, but id like to see him walk one more year.

RE: guesses on score
 

Don't take this as me being harsh on YOU,......but WHY IN THE WORLD wouldsomeone care whether anyone else thinksthey should(or shouldn't) take this deer, or not (I'm not saying you do, either ....lol)? Would it be your first bow kill? Have you killed one bigger than this one? How many bucks can you harvest? How much do you get to hunt? What is YOUR conscious saying?????? Only you can answer these questions. These guys don't have anything to do with it. Period.

Hunting is personal. I have a buck this same size on the property next to me (which I have access to hunt.....and have plenty of trail cam photos of this deer). I'll take him first chance I'm afforded.

Jeff

RE: guesses on score
 

Has alot of potential ! I would pass it will be worth it 2 years down the road.

RE: guesses on score
 

Around 100