Are these all the same buck?
 

I want some opinions here........the first pic is from my game cam last season, and the next one is from earlier this year. The last one is my buck I got this year~ Sure all look like the same, but would like some input! I'm going to do one pic at a time.........hope this works.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

Here is the next one

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

Here is my buck I got...........

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

The second and third look the same but the first has different characteristics than the others.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

Ditto gutcheck

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

Thats what i was thinking too. I didnt even realize until today that I might have a picture of the buch I got this year. The second and third picture really look alike when you have the rack to look at in person.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

4 ME IS NOT THE SAME MAYBE THE SECOND ONE AND THE ONE U KILL BUT NOT THE 1ST

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

all three look completely different to me. I see no reason to believe either of them are the same deer.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

they all 3 look totally differnt to me also

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

2 and 3 look same but 1 is not the same

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

2 and 3 arethe same.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

i really don't know with this one.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

The 1st picture is definately different than the other 2 pictures, the
deer in the 1st picture does not even have the same # of points as
the other 2 deer pictures.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

The 1st pic is definitely none of the others. The 2nd & 3rd might be, but not 100% sure.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

Pic #1 is a different deer than Pic #2 & #3 pretty sure they are the same critter. Not a 100 though.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

How in the %$^* can you guys be so sure? I want you guys on my local crime scene investigation unit. Pics are too small for me to tell..

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

All different deer.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

We're not! But given the lack of clear and compelling evidence before us, I'd say he's innocent.:D

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

I agree with the others, 1st one is not the same as the second two.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

I would agree, 2nd and 3rd pic, maybe. First pic does look like a different deer.

Shane

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

#1 and #2 are the same, #3 is different....First two are alive, third one is dead.:D:);):D:);)

Ohh, you mean antler characteristics....well 2 and 3 look similar, but I can't tell for sure.

#1 could be the same buck, remember you guys, that's his rack from last year and the number of points could change.
But the overall shape and tine angles look different so I would have to say its a different buck.

RE: Are these all the same buck?
 

I think pic 2 and 3 are the same deer.