HuntingNet.com Forums

HuntingNet.com Forums (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/)
-   Black Powder (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/black-powder-23/)
-   -   is bore butter necessary? (https://www.huntingnet.com/forum/black-powder/266928-bore-butter-necessary.html)

rshunter32 10-07-2008 05:33 PM

is bore butter necessary?
 
just wondering if using bore butter is necessary after I clean my rifle? I shoot a t/c triumph.

FG 10-07-2008 05:36 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
No you dont need it. Water based so pretty much the next time you go to swab it out you will find that it had been rusting your bore while you figured it was protecting it.

Rem oil with teflon is a great oil to use in your bore. Swab the bore with a damp patch, allow to set for a few minutes and then use a dry patch to mop up the excess oil.

mountaineer magic 10-07-2008 06:20 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I don't know if it is absolutely necessary but I use it in my Triumph and every other gun I own every time I clean them. Have used it for years and like it

arcticap 10-07-2008 06:20 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
It's not needed, but it's not water based either. It's made with mineral oilandparaffin waxes. People like it because it stays put and clings to the walls of the bore without running down into the breech.
By itself, itdoesn't promote rust. But humidity and residual powder foulingmight if the gun isn't thoroughly cleanedand preserved in the first place.

Semisane 10-07-2008 06:24 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
For me, it's anything but bore butter. I use any light gun oil I have around, or plain old 3-in-1 oil. Rem-oil is excellent.

cayugad 10-07-2008 06:32 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
If you want to use bore butter in your rifle.. go right ahead. Its your rifle. All I will say is there is not place for it in my rifles. My wastebasket yes, my rifles no.

nchawkeye 10-07-2008 07:05 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
Bore Butter is not made for inlines, don't use it in them...Regular gun oil is what is best for an inline...

Bore Butter was developed for side hammer guns, they marketed it as a product that would "season" the bore and
give you many shots between cleaning...Most of us didn't buy it...We realized that while you can season a cast iron
fry pan, gun barrelsare made of steel...

mountaineer magic 10-07-2008 07:24 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 

ORIGINAL: nchawkeye

Bore Butter is not made for inlines, don't use it in them...Regular gun oil is what is best for an inline...

Bore Butter was developed for side hammer guns, they marketed it as a product that would "season" the bore and
give you many shots between cleaning...Most of us didn't buy it...We realized that while you can season a cast iron
fry pan, gun barrelsare made of steel...
actually that is not entirely true. Stainless steel maybe, depending on the type of alloys and percentage , but carbon steel does need seasoned just like cast iron. Do a little research on steels and see , Try wikipedia or even google

saxman1 10-07-2008 07:31 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I have the bore butter in my guns now but after reading the posts of members that I respect VERY MUCH it will come out tomorrow and Rem oil will go in

corey012778 10-07-2008 07:42 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I have used bore butter for has been patch lube and bullet lube.

I have never owned a new muzzy thou. lol

arcticap 10-07-2008 09:28 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
Itcan beused asa breech plug grease,to helpsoften powder residue, as a lubricant on externalmoving parts and as a protectant on surfaces that are exposed to powder fouling during shooting.
It also helps to dissolve & removeanyresidual traces of powder fouling leftin the boreand rifling grooves after cleaning. Swabit in, wait awhile andswab it out, then inspect the clean patch to seeif any black powdertracesare present that were lifted out.

cayugad 10-07-2008 09:36 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
Other then the occassional conical and patch lube, I have very little use for the stuff. I actually make my own lube and like it better. Although I do like the smell of bore butter wintergreen.. :D

Semisane 10-07-2008 10:36 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 

I actually make my own lube and like it better. Although I do like the smell of bore butter wintergreen..
:DMe too. You can go to a shop that has candymakingsupplies and find tiny little bottles of flavoring agents and make your home made lube smell any way you want. Check out the variety.

https://www.lorannoils.com/c-6-super-strength-flavors-candy-oils.aspx Yes, they have wintergreen too. :D

bigmossy 10-08-2008 06:38 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 

ORIGINAL: nchawkeye

Bore Butter is not made for inlines, don't use it in them...Regular gun oil is what is best for an inline...

Bore Butter was developed for side hammer guns, they marketed it as a product that would "season" the bore and
give you many shots between cleaning...Most of us didn't buy it...We realized that while you can season a cast iron
fry pan, gun barrelsare made of steel...
TC would disagree. Each of my Triumphs came with a DVD that STRONGLY recommends the use of bore butter. I believe these DVD's were produced prior to the introduction of the Triumph seriessinceit is never specifically mentioned in the DVD although the Omega appears to be the main"star" of the video.

They (TC) do mention it is neededproper"seasoning" of the barrel too (for the Omega series).

Now, I'm no expert, but would think TC would know what they were talking about. Of course they do make the bore butter so I'm certain it's in their best interest to make sure we all buy it and use it often.

I'm on the fence on this one. Could someone explain in more detail about "seasoning" of a barrel and how bore butter can help or hurt with it ???

nchawkeye 10-08-2008 07:57 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I started shooting these things back in the 70s...I never heard of bore seasoning until T/C started making Bore Butter...

I used to shoot competition, one of the best shooters and builders actually used axle grease as a patch lube...Like Cay, I make
my own so I can make it thick as I like it...

I had a buddy that used the stuff a few years ago, his gun quitgrouping so he bought it to me to fix...I called Knight and they said
don't use it...So T/C say Yes, Knight says No...Kinda like the debate last night, hard to tell who is right...Anyway, I used JB paste on
the barrel, got it back nice and smooth and the gun started grouping again...

As I said, inlines, leave it alone, use oil...Side hammers, there are better home made lubes out there...As far as using to store your guns,
either side hammer or inline....I use a good gun oil...

Johnmorris 10-08-2008 08:31 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I don't like brown barrels. I had one barrel with surface rust after storing with bore butter I quit using it years ago.

sjsfire 10-08-2008 08:32 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I have two inlines and the only thing that touches the inside ofmy barrel after cleaning is Rem Oil with teflon.

arcticap 10-08-2008 09:33 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 

ORIGINAL: bigmossy
I'm on the fence on this one. Could someone explain in more detail about "seasoning" of a barrel and how bore butter can help or hurt with it ???
There's really not any benefit or need to season modern steel with Bore Butter. That's a notionlinked toold wroughtiron barrels.
I've heardoffolks treating their bore with synthetic motor oil toofor better accuracyand they claim thatitabsorbs into the pores of the steel and lasts for a number of shotsmuch like a Slick 50 enginetreatment. Hmmmm.....
But TC actuallyrecommends againstusing Bore Butter when shootingsabots. When asked, they've clearlysaidthat a cleanbore shoots sabotsthe best, yetsome folks use it anyway.
Since the boreneeds to be thoroughly cleaned after shooting there's no seasoning effect tobegainedby using it.
I think that it'ssimply a handy BP patchlube withmultiple uses, but oflimited benefit.

Underclocked 10-08-2008 09:40 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
TC recommends EVERYTHING they sell.

I've got a couple of tubes of the stuff around. Can't remember the last time I actually used any, probably used some to quickly lube a conical to use as a bore slug.

sabotloader 10-08-2008 10:16 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I hate this discussion, because I do not think there is a right answer.... It is another one of the crusadesthat the infamous RW started because somebody suggested something...

I have used bore butter since I began shooting ML's at first I was using it as suggested on the tube , then folowing the advice of other users changed my approach on how I used the stuff. Then over the last 6 or 7 years completely changed that approach and adopted my own method. In the last couple of years I have even give up on BB and do not useit any longer since TC introduced the new T17 patch with Natural Lube 1000.

I long ago figured out that BB or for that matter T17 did not season a barrel as the thought is intended - your barrel is not a cast iron skillet. I do believe it alleviates fouling in fact I am positive of it. I use it in my trap guns and especially the chokes. Some of you that shoot shotguns a lot pull your uncleaned choke - put a little BB on you little finger or use a T17 patch and run it gently into and around in the the choke... course your finger will turn black as it leaches plastic and powder residue out of the choke.

Another belief I have, and I have absolutely no way to prove it... I do not get the T7 "crud ring" in any of the ML's that I shoot - I believe that BB and T17 are a factor in reducing that fouling also. As an example last week shooting PRB's in Colfax I switched from my normal load of GOEX to T7... - the old timers had convinced me that I needed to use GOEX so I would not have to patch the barrelafter each shotas i normally do whenusing T7. Well, in Colfax while shooting T7 - i did notswab after each shoot and things went great.

So, for just me, BB and T17 work great and I will continue touse it in the manner that I do - applying it in in a very hot barrel... allow some cooling then dry patching the bulk back out... At this point I should also say that I do not believe that either of these products will protect the metal from rust. The last step in my process is the application of a healthy coat of Slip 2000 a synthetic bore oil, then dry patch the majority of that back out of the barrel unless the gun is going to be stored for a long duration.

Just, again, my 2 cents...

Oh! the question is BB necessary - NO!

Rebel Hog 10-08-2008 10:23 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
I get into my wife's Cooking Crisco can when I can or Rendered Ckicken Fat or Bacon Fat...:) Many a time I have use spit!:D

Underclocked 10-08-2008 10:46 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
Mike, that one actually was not RWs. This one has been going on since before RW knew one end of a ramrod from the other. :D Actually, looooooong before that time.

I edited this as I can no longer be sure of my memory. :D

sabotloader 10-08-2008 11:04 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
UC


but I think RELYING solelyon BB as a preservative is a mistake
Concurr

slayer_54 10-08-2008 11:14 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
i like it.it works for me. but i have a stainless barrel. but my loads go down alot easier.

SteveBNy 10-08-2008 11:55 AM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
It's only needed if you own stock in TC:D

As UC said, of course they recomend it - it's one of their products.

Just like CVA recomends PB;)

Steve

andrewjoseph 10-08-2008 04:33 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 
Would you put bore butter in your shotgun? Would you put it in a .243? If you awnser no then I would not put in in your inline. I like Barriade byBirchwood Casey when the gun is going to sit for a while.

bigmossy 10-08-2008 08:15 PM

RE: is bore butter necessary?
 

ORIGINAL: andrewjoseph

Would you put bore butter in your shotgun? Would you put it in a .243? If you awnser no then I would not put in in your inline. I like Barriade byBirchwood Casey when the gun is going to sit for a while.
Would you shoot corrosive ammo out of them and clean them with water-based solvents?


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:17 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.