Is this really muzzleloading?
03-11-2007, 06:18 PM
#11
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location:
Posts: 3,246
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
ORIGINAL: HuntAway
I have gone from the 30-06 world to the in-line world to the flintlock world for deer hunting. I need / like the adventure.
I have gone from the 30-06 world to the in-line world to the flintlock world for deer hunting. I need / like the adventure.
03-11-2007, 06:19 PM
#12
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 3,092
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
My guess is that CVA Electra thang will fall flatly on its face as a failure. I personally will neither own nor hunt with one but I wouldn't think less of someone for trying it, where legal.
I'm more curious about what's up with the good old RWS 1075+ percussion caps.
I'm more curious about what's up with the good old RWS 1075+ percussion caps.
03-11-2007, 06:39 PM
#13
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Tri Cities, Washington
Posts: 1,616
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
ORIGINAL: roundball
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
03-12-2007, 06:02 AM
#14
Typical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Upstate New York-Broome County
Posts: 597
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
ORIGINAL: roundball
Not to me...none of the so called modern high technology, hight performance, scope sighted, long range, smokeless powder buringingrifles that happen to load from the front aremuzzleloaders at all in thespirit of what real muzzleloading is all about.
They are nothing more than advanced high technology products taking advantage of the loosely written regulations for muzzleloading seasons that were clearly set up decades ago by and for traditional style muzzleloading enthusiaststo keep the real sidelockmuzzleloading tradition alive, just like special bow seasons were established to recognize and preserve the uniqueness of bow hunting...and is why high tech, high performance "scoped crossbows" are generally not allowed in bow seasons.
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
Not to me...none of the so called modern high technology, hight performance, scope sighted, long range, smokeless powder buringingrifles that happen to load from the front aremuzzleloaders at all in thespirit of what real muzzleloading is all about.
They are nothing more than advanced high technology products taking advantage of the loosely written regulations for muzzleloading seasons that were clearly set up decades ago by and for traditional style muzzleloading enthusiaststo keep the real sidelockmuzzleloading tradition alive, just like special bow seasons were established to recognize and preserve the uniqueness of bow hunting...and is why high tech, high performance "scoped crossbows" are generally not allowed in bow seasons.
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
03-12-2007, 10:47 AM
#16
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 501
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
ORIGINAL: cascadedad
Same old sick, tired and lame arguement. That's my opinion.
ORIGINAL: roundball
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
Modern inlines today are already matching/exceeding some centerfire ballistics, yet centerfireshave always been prohibited from muzzleloader seasons for reasons obvious to every 12 year old in the country.
This electronic ignition variation of a modern high tech "MUZZLELOADER" is just the next in a long line of attempts to make deer hunting easy for "arm chair hunters" who have not or will not spend the time learning the craft of real muzzleloading and deer hunting.
Opinions were asked for, the aboveis justmy personal opinion...others may vary of course.
The poster asked for opinions on his question, not"your opinion about my opinion"...so your response to menot only fails to address the poster's question,it wastes a lot ofgood bandwidth, andmakes no difference to me personally whatsoever.
People either have legitimate logic for their positions or they don't.
Those whodon'tresort to attacking those who do.
03-12-2007, 10:49 AM
#17
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 501
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
ORIGINAL: Chasam60
Do you hunt with a recurve or a longbow? There are some who claim that a compound is a high tech high performancebow that has no place in the special bow seasons that were established to preserve the uniqueness of bow hunting. Just an opinion of course-but they may be right.
Do you hunt with a recurve or a longbow? There are some who claim that a compound is a high tech high performancebow that has no place in the special bow seasons that were established to preserve the uniqueness of bow hunting. Just an opinion of course-but they may be right.
Good one !
03-12-2007, 10:54 AM
#18
Dominant Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 21,193
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
I have no problem with any one's opinion whether I agree or disagree with it. After all it is their opinion and if they hold true to their beliefs, more power to them.I can actually respect that. While I might not be real worried about the spirit of the hunt or acting like my forefathers (still looking for two of them ... 
) if someone else likes to use that as their motivation, that's fine.
As for opening up this can of worms. Not interested. Its been hashed over too much.
) if someone else likes to use that as their motivation, that's fine.As for opening up this can of worms. Not interested. Its been hashed over too much.
03-12-2007, 11:33 AM
#19
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Slower Lower Delaware 1st State
Posts: 1,776
RE: Is this really muzzleloading?
A battery operated Smoke Pole.Guess you better pack a spare battery when huntin.
Pull the trigger on the 10pnt you been scoutin and 'snap' - Dead Battery
That's way over the Top for me.An obvious attempt to gain some market share in the sale of Smoke Poles.
Hey - if its legal in your state - to each his/her own.No sense in hunters bashing each other over a 9volt CVA Smoke Pole.
Buy one - in a hundred years it might be worth a ton of money
Pull the trigger on the 10pnt you been scoutin and 'snap' - Dead Battery
That's way over the Top for me.An obvious attempt to gain some market share in the sale of Smoke Poles.
Hey - if its legal in your state - to each his/her own.No sense in hunters bashing each other over a 9volt CVA Smoke Pole.
Buy one - in a hundred years it might be worth a ton of money
