npaden

Okay. Reading some more it looks like I exaggerated to. It looks like only about 45% of Montana is Public Land. I found one site that said 36,000,000 acres of Federal Land and another that said 5,750,000 acres of State land so that would only be about 45% of the total 93 million acres of land in Montana. Of course that's more public land in Montana than there is total land in Florida but actually it looks like Florida may have a higher % of public land than Montana does. I would have never guessed that!

srwshooter

whitetails, eastern whitetails in the mountains, they are way harder to hunt.

Montana Bob

Muley's Hands down.

elkslayer338

Whitetail are a bit smarter then a mule-deer so offermore challenge.
but I love Mule deer hunting two . Note I still stalk both breeds, no blinds,no stands, no bait. I would say for me it would be whitetail,I have hadthem bucks do somepretty sneaky crap on me. " keeps it fun when their not dumb"


Note I could rise from the grave to go Elk hunting that is my calling..

CervidSlayer

In regards to Florida...It is the only state that is completely surrounded by two different bodies of water.
Did you forget that most of all the beaches in Florida are public "State" land. And some of the beaches are "Federal" land...What a state.

James B

Mule deer because there there are almost no whitetails in the unit where I own land.

trouthunter

It depends on what is out the back door of my future hunting cabin. If it is Mulies, then I'll hunt them. Whitetails...then I guess I'll hunt them.

If I really have to choose one or the other...forever...then I'll move and just hunt Elk

Jeff Ovington

High Country Mulies..

GooseHunter Jr.

Mule deer all the way.....just like the challenge they bring by being in some of the hardest places to get.

CBM SC

Big whitetails in the Southeast are pretty tough to kill with the long seasons and pressure they get !! It seems almost impossible to get one sometimes !! And it makes you appreciate them when you do get one !!

I have hunted mulie's out west and it was incredible hunting........spot and stalk with a bow seemed about as good as it gets !! I have hard time imagining that Iwould never do that again!!

But with the question at hand...........killing a big whitetail around here is the most challenging hunting I have ever been faced with !! So I would have to go with the illusive whitetail !!