I agree with bowfanatic. is sounds like you should move the rest to the right....but sometimes you go too far, and it makes it look like you didn't go far enough.
PERSONALLY, I would eye it up for center shot, then tune it with broadheads (works much the same as bare shaft tuning, but your FOC is correct, and you don't have to broadhead tune afterwards).
get the field points and broadheads to hit the same hole, and don't worry about paper tuning.