If that deer was killed by a 9 year old his first day in the woods with his father on a cool winter morning with nobody around but the two of them it would be a huge trophy for both. However if the same deer was shot by someone in pike county Illinois who owns an outfitting company and has 30 deer score over 160 hanging on his wall then it's probably just another day in the woods. I don't care what it's shot with as long as it's memorable, that's a trophy to me.