I have a Marlin 444s and love it. I got it primarily for bear (haven't got one yet). I took a 250lb wild boar at 30 yards running. He hit the ground like a rock. Guide said he never saw one die that quick. It shoots great and is alot more accurate than I expected. I punched a deer at 75 yards broadside behind the shoulders and it ran 50 yards. Shoot both and I think you will pick the Marlin!
Tim