Strictly based on price, I'd suggest the Scout. However, you can get some good deals on RFs on eBay. I purchased a Busnell Compact 800 last year for less than $200. It seems to have very good optics and has been a pleasure to use. I'm of the mind that a RF is a scouting tool. I use it alot during the pre-season, but not much while hunting. I've marked enough of the rocks/trees/etc. around my stands to not need it during bow season. My lease is thick enough that I won't get many long shots.