Me personally,. I would be out in SD on an Indian reservation, the tag is then a either or deer tag, so IF you see a BIG whitetail you can then still shoot that
my last hunts out , was seeing 15-20 bucks a day(not all big by any means) but seen lots of both species, a few 160+ mule deer WAY out there , and just too far for me to go after, but some stud's
tags are first come first serve and you can then double dip if you like and try for a state tag and maybe make it a two buck trip, if you time things right!
or you can buy a over the counter archery tag and still have a shot at a second buck if you tag out on the reservation?
traveling far (from PA) I like to make my trips worth while and get as much hunting in as possible
SO< it gets my vote here