I've never hunted with a crossbow before, but I have shot one a time or two. IMO, nothing is challenging about shooting a crossbow. I've shot a few deer with a compound & I've missed a few deer with one as well. I love a challenge & nothing is more challenging than pulling the strings back on a bow with a deer in the vicinity, not to mention just shooting a deer period with a compound from 20 yards or so away. If it was me, I'd definitely go with the compound. Might could find a used one that is in very good shape thats less than what you're willing to spend. Nothings better than saving some money!