Originally Posted by
grinder67
Wouldn't body size factor in to the appearance of the rack size? Not sure what your deer weighs but just thinking a WV deer wouldn't be an accurate comparison to a Kansas deer based on the fact that i have always heard Kansas deer are heavy compared to the same age WV deer. Its all just my opinion but no way do I believe that second deer is only 118 inches. Guess I never will know
top buck may or may not be a wv deer, pulled it off the net cause it was a pic of approx. the same angle and was basicly the same shape of rack and an 8 point, and it has a known score of 126, bottom buck is from ok, not ks. believe what you wish. My hunting buddy killed an 8 pt. this past season, a bit weak in the brows but scored 143, the buck had 26" mainbeams, and 22.5" inside spread. it takes an exceptional 8 to score 140.
here is a link to some bucks that either barely made 125" P&Y min. or barely did not, look at the 130's and 140's in there
http://forums.bowsite.com/TF/bgforum...orum=4#3086109
RR