I'm not ashamed to admit I chose # 1.
I get a trophy and meat for the freezer. Ive found little difference in meat quality between the young and old. Plus, shooting mature bucks and no does allows the heard to build.
I don't shoot hen Mallards or hen Pheasants either. It's the same principle.
Now, I have shot does and will do it again but out of the selections, mine makes since to me.