Doc
Topgun beat me to the Texas Ranch scenario.
Tell me that somehow, hunting a 30000 acre ranch in those 'Senderos' (sp.?) is not akin to fenced hunting. Those ranchers and directors know every buck on that ranch. Knows their habits probably better than that of their Spouses.
What's the difference? Nothing. Both can be considered Fair Chase regardless of P&Y or B&C bylaws, YMMV.
Maybe ranch or Fenced hunting isn't for you but for you to cast your unrequested opinion on what is fair chase isn't fair the the Post or the Author.
Yep, my $.02