Am I wrong about the egg thing???? I know of two seperate instances around here where this question came up, but in both cases upon pulling the guts from the birds eggs were found, and ya can't argue with that! I know in the pic it's hard to tell if its a spur or not but the guy said it did in fact have some very small nubs. To me the plumage thing seems hard to go by since we are just looking at a picture and slight variations in plumage could make it difficult. I ain't saying anybody is right or wrong here, I'm sure no expert in this area but this has got me very curious to find out in fact what it truely is.