well the proper answer is.......depends. Need to know more about your hunting conditions and the game. Small fast moving critters, heavy brush, etc.......you probably need a shotgun. Slow animals or animals that will sit still for a shot, or maybe you need to make a headshot because you dont want to damage the pelt.......rifle. Yeah im sure youve heard a lot that cancels each other out because either gun could be the right choice depending on the circumstances