While not on the poll, I like the Glock 27 for carry. Nice and compact but still holds 9+1, and can accept mags from its' .40sw chambered brothers...
If you've got a range nearby that rents handguns it sure would be a good thing to do before committing. I can honestly say that the Glock 27 is the first Glock I ever handled that I really liked and knew right away I had to have one...