The best one is the one that both fits you and you can afford without taking out a second mortage on. They all work, just to varying degrees of dependability. How much are you going to be useing it? Looking to shoot 3-1/2" shells for geese or turkeys? Looking for cheap and not get kicked into semi-consciousness? Walk-in hunting or from a boat/blind? Myself, I shoot Winchester SX2's and Browning Gold.