If you are hitting big bones like shoulder bones you are aiming in the wrong place.
nobody aims for shoulder bones, c'mon you know that, and you also know its common to hit them
If your setup produces enough energy and momentum, it is hard to beat these heads for leaving a good blood trail and getting a passthru.
its actually EASY to beat these heads, just (A) use a broadhead that cannot fail to open and (B) has much better penetration qualities
I submit any broadhead you would have shot with that hit you made would have resulted in very similar results.
I also submit you could have used a dull and rusty bladed Puckett's Bloodtrailer and killed the deer just as dead too ... I don't reccommend that, but it would have gotten the job done.