Oh well, it's only money right? That's true as long as my wife doesn't find out anyway!
I went by Academy at lunch and bought a Mossberg 835 turkey shotgun.
http://www.academy.com/index.php?pag...350-01883-2235
Picked up some Winchester 3 1/2" 1300fps #5 shells and will throw some at a paper circle this weekend. I think it should pattern out a little bit better than my over/under with a full choke. Although the only turkey I ever shot at with the over/under went down like a box of rocks at a whopping 14 yards.