No doubt they are different. The frame and beam curvature is a dead give away. First buck the tips are way wider than the deers brow tines and the second the tips are at or inside the brows. First also is at his ears or wider with spread. Second is way inside his ears spread wise. Also 1st deer the left g4 in almost inline with the g2 and the 2nd deer the left g4 is inbetween the brow and g2 and closer to the brow.