Wolverine 8" Hawthorne w/400 Gram Thinsulate

or

Irish Setter Men's Trail Phantom 600

My local Dicks Sporting goods has them for the same price. I have only tried on the wolverines and they are comfortable. I am waiting for the Irish Setters and should be able to try them early next week. The main difference is the phantoms are camo and 600 gr insulated, 3 lb 1oz. hawthorne that I have is just brown and has 400 gr, 3 lb 14oz.

If both were comfortable and fit correctly, which would you recommend?.

I found limited reviews on the wolverine and nothing on the Irish setter. Can anyone share any experiences with either or comment on the companies reputation and any warranty they may offer?