Kris - I am going to give that a try next time I get the right wind to hunt him.
Here is another video of the 9 pointer and the 12 pointer from yesterday morning...I am guessing the pecking order is established on this farm and the old 9 pointer might be the reason he wont come to the decoy.
I didn't notice while trying to film yesterday but it looks like the 9 pointer postures up and chases him off a little bit.
Enjoy!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZDDBL3E5RY