Of these I have both a similar Bushnell Elite 4200 and Burris Fullfield. I like the Elite much better, especially in low light. It is a bit long and heavy but the optics seem pretty dog-gone good to me for the $$$. Have no experience with the other brand that you mentioned. My Elite is on a 50 cal. Savage ML and has held up fine. Probably 125-150 shots. Not much of a duration test I know, but at least it has not shown any problems so far.