I have an 605gr arrow with a 300 grain tip. A 100gr brass insert and a 200gr Muzzy Phantom. Insert and phantom cost less together than most 125gr BH's. I agree there may not be a need for an arrow like that for hunting deer but I don't see any downside to it at all. There is minimum that is needed for hunting deer but it is the rare person that hunts with just what is needed.