I'd let him take the deer, because its a shame to waste it. That would be the last time he ever hunted that property. Period. Some people lose their minds when they see a deer. If he wanted meat, he should have shot a doe. Kick him off your property, and I'll guarentee he'll be calling again next year, whining that he doesnt have a place to go and he is very sorry....

I prefer:

First time F me
Second time F you