RE: What's your area/woods capable of?
We kill a few P&Y bucks every year off of our lease.
There have been two B&C deer taken off of the same ground in the last six years.
We try to stick to a basic "let them go so they can grow" management plan. Having said that, we don't tell anyone who is there to kill their first deer that they have to let small bucks walk. We tell them to shoot the first one that looks good to them and after that it needs to be P&Y or better.