Both are great heads and will tip over the deer no problem as long as you put the BH in the right place. I guess most all of them will doth that right!
I've shot the Gators for 13 years now, the original rage, 2" cut, rear deploying, no oring, fly the same as my field points. that 2" cut wipes them out thats for sure, and like the others have said they are on sale now for $21!
All they guys that I know that have tried them now shoot them.

Best of luck!

They don't like the gator to the heart area!