RE: western new york deer hunting
I don't have any idea what you offer, such as how much land you have exclusive rights to, what the bag limits are, is lodging/food included, do you process the deer or at least have facilities to let hunters process what they shoot if they choose to, etc.
All of that aside,you should charge what the market will bear. If you're booked, or at least busy, the price is probably right.
Full-service guided hunts are not my thing. If I were to do one, I'd rather pay for lodging but hunt on my own.